News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Anonymously Post/Compare Startup Salary & Equity Offers by jacquesm on Wednesday January 26, 2011 @06:19AM (#2142918)
Encrypted email addresses don't need to be broken, all you need to do is run the addresses using the same hashing algorithm against a set of known addresses to see which ones pop up. Plenty of HN'ers have their email addresses out in the open.

If email addresses are stored 'encrypted' how can they be kept 'confidential', you store them for a reason or you don't need to store them at all, hashed or not.

What gain do you have from storing the hashed address?

Re:Anonymously Post/Compare Startup Salary & Equity Offers by rdl on Wednesday January 26, 2011 @06:51AM (#2142979)
If I were creating the service, I'd want the email or some other "is an actual credible person" credential, but wouldn't store it afterward. Referrer being hackernews might actually be sufficient to not require email.

The best credential would be something like "is a member of FB or LinkedIn with a sufficiently filled in profile" but nothing personally identifying.

For the traditional version of this (alumni association stats), you have a trusted third party (the association), or restricting access to people on 18.0.0.0/8 or who have kerberos credentials, although logging anything personally identifying.