News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:BrainNet: A Multi-Person Brain-to-Brain Interface by dekhn on Friday November 01, 2019 @02:08PM (#21421971)
From what I can tell, if this work is actually correct it is an extraordinary accomplishment: we can both read and perceptibly write information in the brain, and transmit it between individuals directly. I mean, sure we can do that already by talking or waving hands or any number of other methods, but this means that perception-coding is effectively a solved problem.
Re:BrainNet: A Multi-Person Brain-to-Brain Interface by marviel on Friday November 01, 2019 @04:43PM (#21423504)
I have not read the entirety of the detailed paper, so I cannot be sure that my critique is bulletproof, but based on my cursory reading, the following critique:

Unfortunately, because the information transmitted is a single bit, I'm concerned that there are all kinds of ways this sort of system could amount to "are they using this very, very general part of their brain or not?" transmission. On the receivers side the decoding could be accomplished not by "feeling the thoughts" in the sense we would expect (i.e. the thoughts of another person inside your head), but rather by having that single bit of information felt by the electric stimulation of the skin of the scalp, etc.

Granted, they do say they introduced noise into the signal -- but again, if the information is just one bit, and you're aware of exactly the information's timing, etc, it makes decoding it a lot easier. (No "When does the signal start?" problem)

I am long-term BCI/CBI Bullish, but I'm concerned this is less of a "new age" moment, and more of a "clever headline" moment

Re:BrainNet: A Multi-Person Brain-to-Brain Interface by noobiemcfoob on Friday November 01, 2019 @05:22PM (#21423833)
I believe some research out of Duke had already done similar things with chimps, but bringing it to humans is major. Each of these studies becomes a proof of concept for what "should" be true of the brain, but theories fall flat all the time. Each lays a brick in the foundation for building a true BCI.

I'm most excited that this was done with only an 8-channel OpenBCI headset, 16-bit, for the "Receiver". The "Senders" had a much stronger/better headset, but seeing open hardware show up in this is awesomely inspiring!