Re:Forget Quora, New York's Stack Overflow Is Killing It
by BrandonM on Wednesday January 26, 2011 @02:08AM
(#2142453)
> Programmers by their nature self-organize. I don't think that's generally true for other groups
Where does this come from? I think people by their nature self-organize. Programmers are often less social than their non-programming brethren.
SO is interesting. I think their format for programmers and technical people works exceedingly well. The main SO site itself absolutely kills it for programming related questions, much more than mailing lists, forums and every other programming Q&A site before it.
That being said, I really wonder how applicable that model is to other fields. The other original trilogy sites (serverfault and superuser) haven't mirrored SO's success. I wonder how well the other incubated sites have done or will do, particularly in already crowded spaces like for games and gadgets.
Programmers by their nature self-organize. I don't think that's generally true for other groups although it'd be undoubtedly true for some.
So I like Joel and Jeff. I like SO although I've been fairly inactive there for months. I like the platform but I'm just not convinced of the viability of building a large portfolio of niche verticals on that idea.