News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:OAuth Will Murder Your Children by StavrosK on Tuesday January 25, 2011 @05:29PM (#2141219)
Your point about Android is half correct, yes I like seeing what the app needs to access, but I don't see why. Why does your calculator app need access to the internet? I know the author can just offer some bullshit excuse, but it's better than nothing...
Re:OAuth Will Murder Your Children by archangel_one on Tuesday January 25, 2011 @05:51PM (#2141290)
I would very much like the checkboxes in Android too, although obviously they'd place a greater burden on developers. For example, I tried installing the official XBMC remote app a while back; it requested all sorts of crazy permissions ("read SMS" etc) which they were intending to use for debatably useful features but I ended up not installing it because of the privacy concerns. In the end I installed a third-party remote app which didn't ring as many alarm bells on installation, but I'd have been happier to stick with the 'official' one if I could selectively disable some of the permissions they wanted.

I can certainly see why that isn't an option; it'd make things much harder for developers if they suddenly have to test against different sets of security permissions. But it's on my wishlist.

Re:OAuth Will Murder Your Children by ZoFreX on Wednesday January 26, 2011 @04:26AM (#2142723)
XBMC remote needs that because it has a "show your texts on the TV" feature which you really, really shouldn't turn on. Trust me.

It's a shame that you can't pick and choose, as a user, because they can't remove that permission without breaking that feature for everyone [who?] that uses it. It's open-source though, so the good news is you could remove that permission and feature yourself if you really want it (you should: it's pretty nifty).

Re:OAuth Will Murder Your Children by StavrosK on Tuesday January 25, 2011 @06:36PM (#2141440)
Oh, no, I don't need checkboxes (I realise it would make development hard). I only need a justification under each permission to see if the app has a good reason to want to read my texts, but I'm quite happy denying it as a whole.
Re:OAuth Will Murder Your Children by btilly on Tuesday January 25, 2011 @10:04PM (#2141938)
They need access to the internet so they can dynamically fetch the ads they are going to show you which is where they get their money from.

This has the advantage of generally being true, and being unobjectionable enough that most people will grant access.

Re:OAuth Will Murder Your Children by StavrosK on Tuesday January 25, 2011 @11:04PM (#2142079)
That was an example, though.