Re:Is Death Reversible?
by kevin_thibedeau on Thursday October 31, 2019 @02:16PM
(#21411892)
You are not immutable. Your body is already a ship of Theseus.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
That's true, but that doesn't mean if you build an identical ship next to mine that your ship is "the same ship."
Further, I'll be pissed if the one I'm on sinks. The identical one sailing off into the distance is cold comfort to me.
But the system of continuous electrical processes that make up your consciousness is immutable, from your perspective.
If it is perfectly transferred to another vessel, as a series of direct connections (maybe some kind of neuron-based "wire"), then maybe it could be considered the same continuous consciousness.
The body around it, from the perspective of the system, doesn't matter. It can be replaced forever as long as the system remains continuous.
Re:Is Death Reversible?
by AstralStorm on Saturday November 02, 2019 @09:09AM
(#21427471)
Yes, but it's a massive and complex feedback system. So every replaced piece is tuned back to be a good to perfect replacement - including thought.
When that does not happen you get hallucinations or cancers, for example.
You could build an empirically accurate copy of the ship in this way - not perfect but very close.