Do you think the right thing for the RIAA to do instead would have been to not offer to settle, but just open with a lawsuit and insist on a trial? Or are they supposed to just ignore people who they have very good evidence are massive infringers?
Not to mention that in most cases that evidence was obtained in an illegal manner (by people that were acting as if they were private investigators, but had no license to do so). Is that okay too? Should the RIAA not be responsible for it's own transgressions because they were just 'innocent mistakes' in the pursuit of a much higher goal (corporate profits)?
What about when the RIAA tries to sue people for sharing songs by artists that the RIAA has no legal standing to represent (I'd argue that moves like this are either made because: 1. the RIAA naively view itself as some entity that 'all of music' must pass through or 2. it's part of some targeted plan to make sure that the rest of the world thinks/believes that the RIAA controls all music)?
"We think that you have wronged us, so pay us $4k or else be forced to defend yourself in court where if you win, you have thousands of dollars in lawyer/court fees, and if you lose you have thousands of dollars in lawyer/court fees in addition to whatever the damages awarded are."
That you're completely ignoring this possibility says to me that you feel everyone accused by the RIAA is guilty until proven innocent (in your eyes at least).