News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Twitter to ban political advertising by yters on Wednesday October 30, 2019 @06:00PM (#21403293)
What defines a political ad? For example are prolife ads political, even if they mention no laws or politics? What about ads that do not mention politics but are targeted to influence policy? Seems like an ambiguous category except for outright promoting particular candidates and laws.
Re:Twitter to ban political advertising by exergy on Wednesday October 30, 2019 @06:16PM (#21403449)
This level of pedantry drives me up the wall. Not everything needs to be invented from first principles.

Profile ads are banned, yes, because they involve teh candidates. Policy ads are banned because they again involve politics.

We can start anywhere! Let's say 'nothing from any entity that receives money from a political party'. Or 'anything mentioning election candidates'. Or 'anything with certain keywords in it'.

What you're not stopping to ask yourself is 'who are the kinds of people that need to advertise about politics'? Yep, exactly the kinds of dickheads you don't want polluting our information streams with their bullshit. Out with all of them!

Re:Twitter to ban political advertising by hailwren on Wednesday October 30, 2019 @06:31PM (#21403609)
It's not pedantry at all. Look at F1's battle with cigarette advertising for a concrete example. Certainly, explicit advertising is easy to stop, but there are many ways of advertising things surreptitiously.

A great example of this is Ferrari's evolution to avoid the F1 cigarette ban. They started with the word Marlboro on the side of their car, then they moved to a barcode that resembled a pack of cigarettes, and now they are partnered with a front company called Mission Winnow (google it, it's really interesting) that is widely believed to be subliminal advertising for Marlboro.

Re:Twitter to ban political advertising by pm90 on Wednesday October 30, 2019 @06:54PM (#21403836)
What point are you trying to make? The system seems working as intended if Ferrari is going to such great lengths to avoid explicit advertisement.

There will always be those who break laws, doesn’t mean that we should stop making laws.

Re:Twitter to ban political advertising by hailwren on Wednesday October 30, 2019 @09:05PM (#21404723)
The point is that this is a policy that is hard to enforce because it is ambiguous. The system worked as intended if you think that the point was to make only the most well-financed and technically savvy advertisers able to receive a benefit.

Laws don't have anything to do with this thread?

Re:Twitter to ban political advertising by pm90 on Thursday October 31, 2019 @02:57AM (#21406305)
> as intended if you think that the point was to make only the most well-financed and technically savvy advertisers able to receive a benefit.

Your argument is that breaking a law is expensive and only those with money can break it so why bother with laws. Beyond ridiculous.

The example you’re using is also not convincing. Statistically insignificant amount of people know or care enough to watch F1 races.

Re:Twitter to ban political advertising by hailwren on Thursday October 31, 2019 @10:56AM (#21409494)
> The example you’re using is also not convincing. Statistically insignificant amount of people know or care enough to watch F1 races.

We have 1 user on the internet vs $1 Billion in advertising budget. I'm going to trust that Philip Morris is better at quantifying the effect here.

> Your argument is that breaking a law is expensive and only those with money can break it so why bother with laws. Beyond ridiculous.

This still has nothing to do with laws. It's an important distinction to make between laws and corporate policy because one carries very high punishments whilst the other is mostly without recourse.

My argument is in no way proscriptive. Only descriptive.

Re:Twitter to ban political advertising by pm90 on Thursday October 31, 2019 @11:48AM (#21410053)
The example that you used was specifically in the context of corporations getting around anti-tobacco laws. Not corporate policy against tobacco advertisement, but laws. I stand by my assessment that its a bad example to make the point you're trying to make.

> It's an important distinction to make between laws and corporate policy because one carries very high punishments whilst the other is mostly without recourse.

I agree with this.

Re:Twitter to ban political advertising by hailwren on Thursday October 31, 2019 @12:00PM (#21410173)
> The example that you used was specifically in the context of corporations getting around anti-tobacco laws. Not corporate policy against tobacco advertisement, but laws. I stand by my assessment that its a bad example to make the point you're trying to make.

This is mostly incorrect. There are _some_ countries where tobacco advertising laws are the reason for Formula 1's tobacco advertising ban, but the rule being circumvented is FIA's tobacco ban. Interestingly, in countries where tobacco advertising is illegal, Ferrari often changes their livery to not include Mission Winnow.

Re:Twitter to ban political advertising by exergy on Wednesday October 30, 2019 @06:52PM (#21403827)
With each such iteration, the advertising punch is diluted. At this point, it's a stretch to imagine someone seeing the mirrored M-W logo and going "God, I need a smoke". In this way, we are all the better for it.
Re:Twitter to ban political advertising by yters on Wednesday October 30, 2019 @08:52PM (#21404659)
It's a real to life point. Live Action's prolife ads were taken down for being 'political' even though the ads have nothing to do with politics.
Re:Twitter to ban political advertising by ben509 on Wednesday October 30, 2019 @06:28PM (#21403567)
People not thinking things through, which, yes, means working them out from first principles, are why we have so many stupid and broken laws, policies, regulations, etc.

> Yep, exactly the kinds of dickheads you don't want polluting our information streams with their bullshit. Out with all of them!

I'm sure you'll be shocked and outraged when a story lands in a few months because someone you like is protesting this policy.

Re:Twitter to ban political advertising by exergy on Wednesday October 30, 2019 @06:45PM (#21403754)
And you're going to tell me a bunch of anons on HN are bout to invent it from first principles?!

While 'we' (I'm not American) might have plenty of stupid laws, we also have some very good ones. We've gotten there by taking necessarily-flawed first steps. I have no doubt Twitter will overlook something. But I'm glad they're doing it anyway, and we will get somewhere better in steps. It's better than navel gazing about "What's a law anyway?"

Also, granted, GP didn't explicitly state that he's against the law, but this kind of smug, condescending slippery slope argument keeps getting brought up all over HN, hence my over the top reaction. So many thread seem to devolve into this kind of pointless "Yeah but define <> first" at the hands of Rationalists™ and are worse for it. They get nowhere and it makes for infuriating reading.

Re:Twitter to ban political advertising by nicoburns on Wednesday October 30, 2019 @06:06PM (#21403361)
It's not that hard. The UK (and I believe most of Europe) has heavily regulated political advertising. Politicians can't advertise on billboards here, and TV slots are strictly regulated (and time-limited). I'm not entirely sure what criteria are used, but it seems to work reasonably well.
Re:Twitter to ban political advertising by dabeeeenster on Wednesday October 30, 2019 @06:21PM (#21403514)
The entire problem in the UK is that digital ads are almost completely unregulated (or regulated so pathetically as to be unregulated).

If facebook follow this, that would be a massive step in the right direction.

Re:Twitter to ban political advertising by ben509 on Wednesday October 30, 2019 @06:28PM (#21403574)
That doesn't mean they're doing it fairly. It just means that people have accepted that certain voices are silenced.
Re:Twitter to ban political advertising by xkjkls on Wednesday October 30, 2019 @06:50PM (#21403804)
It's much easier to adjudicate what is and isn't political than what is and isn't honest.
Re:Twitter to ban political advertising by SmellyGeekBoy on Wednesday October 30, 2019 @06:37PM (#21403667)
Go on...?
Re:Twitter to ban political advertising by pjc50 on Wednesday October 30, 2019 @06:23PM (#21403532)
.. but not on the internet, which produced the current disaster.
Re:Twitter to ban political advertising by nicoburns on Wednesday October 30, 2019 @06:45PM (#21403763)
Indeed, and newspapers are arguably problematic too. But I think it demonstrates that regulation can be done without the definition of what it covers being too controversial.
Re:Twitter to ban political advertising by danso on Wednesday October 30, 2019 @06:15PM (#21403440)
It's been defined here:

https://business.twitter.com/en/help/ads-policies/restricted...

edit: This is a better link, as it defines the more general term of "political content", which covers both campaigns and issue advocacy:

https://business.twitter.com/en/help/ads-policies/restricted...

Re:Twitter to ban political advertising by StevenRayOrr on Wednesday October 30, 2019 @06:10PM (#21403405)
Lots of democracies have legal definitions for what counts as political advertising. Obviously Twitter doesn't have to use those definitions, but there are fairly clear guidelines in a number of jurisdictions. And it doesn't have to be a situation where they set rules for life: taking a firm apolitical stance on advertising likely requires reassessing the rules over time. But it is doable.

What will be really interesting is whether Twitter tries to work with governments or whether they unilaterally come to their own rules. There be dragons on both fronts.

Re:Twitter to ban political advertising by enraged_camel on Wednesday October 30, 2019 @06:04PM (#21403343)
>>What defines a political as?

It's like porn: hard to define precisely, but you know it when you see it.