Re: A military historian’s analysis of Spartan myth
by jcranmer on Wednesday October 30, 2019 @05:58PM
(#21403273)
But only focusing on the good is definitely a trend that happens a lot--it's called romanticizing. And the ultimate thesis here is that Sparta has been heavily romanticized in modern culture: to modern people, Sparta is the epitome of a proud, independent, martial ethos, when in actuality it was a society led by indoctrinated child soldiers whose military prowess was middling at best and whose military reputation was overrated, even contemporaneously.
Re: A military historian’s analysis of Spartan myth
by autokad on Wednesday October 30, 2019 @06:09PM
(#21403384)
> "But only focusing on the good is definitely a trend that happens a lot--it's called romanticizing."
It doesn't appear that way to me at least. The tired trend I see "hey, you see that thing you like, here let me rub shit all over it. Why do you like it? stop fantasizing, cant you see that I found something bad in it so you are obligated to hate the whole thing". Case in point.
I don't think that's how admiration generally works. I admire Steve Jobs on many things, but he was a cruel human being to some. When I see a sports star, I don't need to know 'the whole picture' to admire their amazing catch or dedication to training. That doesn't make it 'horrid'.