News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Is Stack Exchange in violation of NY labor law by using v... by pimterry on Wednesday October 30, 2019 @10:53AM (#21398379)
> especially on the small sites, it’s acceptable for moderators to be inactive for long periods of time

Interesting!

I can see that being a case against the original point then: if moderators really are free to work or not work however they'd like, then that seems to suggest that they don't match this test, and they're nothing like employees at all.

Do you have to turn up enough to keep up with the moderation queue on those small sites though? If there were a whole bunch of flags waiting on a small site for a while, and as a moderator you weren't helping out, would you lose your moderator status there?

Re:Is Stack Exchange in violation of NY labor law by using v... by klmr on Wednesday October 30, 2019 @10:59AM (#21398454)
That’s exactly what happened, and no, I didn’t lose my status. There are internal metrics for showing individual moderators’ activity but — at least while I was a moderator —these were purely FYI, and not used to enforce activity. I eventually resigned because I was aware that my inactivity was causing backlog that created more work for other moderators. I don’t remember exactly what happened next but since moderators are elected yearly by the community I suspect that new elections were held. However, I need to emphasise that I was relatively inactive for more than a year, and completely inactive for many months.