Tabbing/windowing is a nice bonus; I don't use tiling in tmux all that much, since as you said, it can be done on a different layer, but it is occasionally useful.
My biggest frustration is that there are like ten million places where you need to tweak options to have it behave like a normal shell (scrolling, selection, etc.). It would be nice if these were less quirky by default.
When GUI hangs or crashes (which happens with Kitty sometimes) I really want to be able to start it again and get the same session back. Especially considering that there’s no way to update configuration of running instance and that it loses its remote control socket if you launch another instance on the same socket by accident, hurdles like these can be profoundly inconvenient when you're in the middle of work.
That said, Kitty is really fast and decently scriptable (though perhaps not as flexible and definitely less straightforward than Tmux, primarily due to lack of consistency—some commands are remote-control only, others are internal-only), and with turned off window decorations it can look fantastic and offer all of the screen estate without the inconveniences of native macOS full-screen mode I had to use with Terminal.
But you're super right, I have so many little "quirky" things that just don't work right, like I used to be able to easily double click a line and it would just copy it to a buffer; pasting from my host OS requires different key bindings, and my TMUX config file has slowly grown as I tried to get it working just right... Might be time for me to learn iTerm2 properly....(maybe I can modify keyboard shortcuts to be like Tmux for moving around to different panes....) But part of me worries about the time when I have to go back to a remote dev env where I'm expected to SSH to a protected source code machine.
some people combine https://wiki.archlinux.org/index.php/Dtach and dvtm in whatever combination they want to get screen/tmux without the giant codebases (I love screen, but I don't love that it still has code in it to connect to serial terminals)
I wish there were a port of cu to Linux, but I haven't come across one yet.
If you just wanted the windowing and tiling, wouldn't a tiling window manager be better? It's kind of weird that you concluded the right layer for window tiling was the terminal emulator.
Personally, I only use the window tiling features of tmux when I'm not already working inside a window manager (like when I'm on a /dev/tty*).
I tried a tiling window manager (not sure which) a long time ago and didn't like it, it felt too heavy-handed and unnatural to me. My daily driver is:
- GNOME Shell ...
- ... with the occasional Super+{Left/Right} for basic half-screen splits (e.g. term on the left and editor on the right)...
- ... and I use a little helper script ( https://github.com/ronjouch/marathon ) to run-or-focus apps.
With these three things, I meet my "simple tiling" needs and keep the flexibility I like from non-tiling WMs.
But Sway looks cool, I'll definitely try it one of these days :) , maybe I'll change my mind.
You can replicate a fish-like feeling in zsh (coloring, completions, etc), but for that you need a plugin manager, a million bajillion finicky plugins, and then configuration/performance hell [1] happens. I tried that, got bored of it, then learned to fish and never looked back at zsh.
That being said, out of the interactive shell I don't like the exoticism of fish as a scripting language; I keep preferring shebanged, shellchecked [2], defensive [3] (ba)sh scripts, they're a stable and portable evil I know.
Also, I'm curious what makes you feel "lack of customization in Fish": what can you customize in Zsh that you cannot in Fish?
[1] https://github.com/zsh-users/zsh-autosuggestions/issues/29 , https://github.com/zsh-users/zsh-autosuggestions/issues/22 , https://github.com/robbyrussell/oh-my-zsh/issues/5569 , https://github.com/zsh-users/zsh-autosuggestions/issues/102 , https://github.com/robbyrussell/oh-my-zsh/issues/6338 . And yeah okay, most of these issues are about one specific plugin, and oh-my-zsh, which is known to be a terrible kitchen sink. Fair. But even then, I prefer fish's "batteries included" (and tested) approach to having to the alternative of doing all the mixing myself and dealing with weird plugins interactions :).
Not blaming the authors/maintainers at all, they're responsive and Tmux is extremely reliable. But in the end, it feels like they're battling to implement features at the wrong layer, and UX suffers.
In the end, I realized I just wanted a good terminal emulator that is {fast, featureful, scriptable, keyboard-friendly}.
If that sounds familiar, give Kitty a try: https://sw.kovidgoyal.net/kitty/ (and run https://fishshell.com/ in it, but that's another discussion :)