Also, I'm not terribly sympathetic to an industry which realized that it was losing sales to piracy, but took 8 years before it actually got around to offering what it's customers were looking for, such that their customers could actually pay for what they wanted. Napster was released in 1999, and while the fact that you could get music for free was nice, what was really appealing was that you could look for any song you wanted, find it instantly, download it, and stick it on your MP3 player. Since then, the music industry tried limiting the catalog of services (like Emusic, which offerred DRM-free MP3 downloads but had a lousy selection), or had incompatible DRM-encrusted services that meant that you would risk losing access to your music collection if you changed computers or MP3 players. It wasn't until Amazon MP3 came around in 2007 offering DRM-free MP3 downloads of a reasonably broad selection that they really offered anything at all competitive with piracy. Spending 8 years training consumers that piracy is not only cheaper, but also easier, more convenient, less hassle, and with a greater selection, and who's surprised that they lost customers in that time frame?
Different people presumably have different preferences, but I'd be most worried about a decline in the total number of musicians above the "make enough to eat" threshhold, which may or may not be reflected by that data. I'm less worried by whether the top 40 musicians make $1m or $5m or $50m each, so if that's the main source of revenue loss, I would care less.
I've tried to find that kind of data, but it doesn't seem to exist, at least anywhere I can get to it.
Also, how much of sales descreasing is because people no longer have to buy an entire collection of songs all at once (a CD, for example) and instead get to pick and choose their songs? I know my music purchasing habits have changed from when I was young. I rarely buy entire albums and usually just nab an individual song here and there.
The price of a gallon of gas in dollars has roughly tripled in the last 30 years. The price of a CD has held constant or declined. New technology allows people to get hit singles at a much lower cost. a cassingle would be in the $6 range, now you can get just the one song for a buck.
I can't see how revenue could go up with the dramatic decline in costs. It's not diamonds or oil, there's not some scarce resource that can be controlled. Making music is so much fun people do it for free. The technical barriers to doing so are pretty much gone.
http://money.cnn.com/2010/02/02/news/companies/napster_music...
How can you argue that piracy increases revenues when revenue for an entire industry is plummeting? Is there another chart somewhere that shows aggregate revenues increasing for some category of media that has been digitized? Is there revenue that that chart does not capture that more than makes up for the lost sales, and that is positively affected by piracy?