Re:We're Incentivizing Bad Science
by knzhou on Tuesday October 29, 2019 @01:37PM
(#21389855)
If you leave CERN to apply for a postdoc or professorship somewhere else, they ask for lots of recommendation letters. That's how they learn what you actually did.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Do you think a recommendation letter is a more objective and better evaluation of what someone actually did? That there is less embellishment, less subjectivity in it than a scientific paper that was meant to reflect on your work as a scientist.
I would expect that recommendation letters heavily favor some individuals for subjective reasons.
As does hiring when a Googler goes to some other company. Nobody is going to see their commits. They have to go on their word, their technical skills, and their references.
The fact that there are other instances when people make subjective decisions is not quite relevant in this instance.
We are talking about the case when authorship on a scientific publication is insufficient evidence that someone had any contribution whatsoever to the paper. So that one needs a recommendation letter, in addition to the authorsip, where the recommendation letter would presumably state, this individual did actually do some work and is not just cruising.