News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Driverless cars are stuck in a jam by vkou on Tuesday October 29, 2019 @01:35PM (#21389838)
> A 16-year-old doesn't get to inherit the experience of the 70-year-old they're replacing. A new self-driving car does inherit the experience of older self-driving cars. They also learn from each other in a way humans can't.

> Human drivers also improve at a rate of O(1). Self-driving cars can share their experience perfectly, so they improve at a rate of O(n). I get a day of driving experience per day. Each one of a million self-driving cars on the road will acquire a million days of driving experience. They won't drive traffic accidents down to zero in a week, but in a few years, if we were to deploy them en masse, they could.

This is all very nice, but if true, why are self-driving cars still unable to drive in snow, avoid crashing into trucks pulled over on the side of the road, or navigate a parking lot without nearly getting t-boned?

The rate of improvement might be O(N) (I strongly doubt it), but the problem may lie in the constant multiplier...

Re:Driverless cars are stuck in a jam by fredophile on Tuesday October 29, 2019 @01:42PM (#21389930)
> why are self-driving cars still unable to drive in snow

Have you seen people driving on the first snowfall of the year?

> or navigate a parking lot without nearly getting t-boned?

Driving in a parking lot is tough. Lots of pedestrians, lots of other cars, and way more people driving in reverse than you'd see in most scenarios.

Re:Driverless cars are stuck in a jam by vkou on Tuesday October 29, 2019 @01:51PM (#21390049)
> Have you seen people driving on the first snowfall of the year?

Most of those people don't have winter tires.

> Driving in a parking lot is tough.

So when is the O(N) rate of growth going to get SDVs to the point of an attentive 16 year old?

Re:Driverless cars are stuck in a jam by fredophile on Tuesday October 29, 2019 @02:11PM (#21390305)
> Most of those people don't have winter tires.

You'd think that they'd drive extra cautiously in snow in that case.

> So when is the O(N) rate of growth going to get SDVs to the point of an attentive 16 year old?

Does it need to beat an attentive 16 year old or does it just need to beat a distracted early to mid 30s parent with a small child or two in the car? Self driving cars only need to be better than the average human to reduce overall accidents. Having said that, I'd probably be more likely to hop into a car driven by a random person than a self driving car that I know is only marginally better than an average human.