Considering how Apple came to their current position doesn't provide much reason for optimism that they can repeat their success of the past ten years (hence the talk of magic). Apple got where they are by leveraging commodity MP3 players into an entire product line of Pods, Pads, and Phones based upon being an early mover in the post Napster music business (and with the app store they even managed to sell a fair number of Macs to iPhone developers). The importance of Napster's demise towards Apple's success should not be underestimated.
Apple could encounter such good fortune again, but it is difficult [of course] to see anything in their current product portfolio, the regulatory environment, or the logistics of digital content delivery that offers similar opportunities [again of course].
Looking deeper, the dearth of new iPad competitors may be more indicative of the size of the actual market for slate devices than an indicator of the shortcomings of Apple's competitors - e.g. the slate type device my UPS driver carries indicates the sort of dedicated device design which benefit businesses and some of the shortcomings of Apple's vision within a business model. Magic doesn't cut it.
You could apply your negative reasoning to most tech companies in this new Dot Com Bubble.
Fact is, Apple has been through positive learning curves.
I think Jobs is a good leader, but the Magic is more widely distributed than that, and this means that Apple is probably a good buy.
While nobody may be able to raise the cash to do a complete acquisition of the whole company, the same financial metrics that make this appealing (if you could raise the cash) make the stock appealing for those who can raise the cash to buy only $3,000 of the company, or $30,000 of the company, or whatever fraction.
Personally, I'm being irrational. When Apple was $13 a share and had $6 in cash, I thought it was a screaming buy, but didn't invest because of fear. Now that failure then is holding me back, as investing now would be confirmation that failing to do so then was a mistake. I felt Apple was outside my circle of competence... but that was a rationalization.
That Apple is the most valuable tech company in the USA is a rationalization that somehow they must go down in value. I don't think that is wise.