News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Launch HN: Carve (YC S19) – Rent Cars from Local Dealerships by GhettoMaestro on Monday October 28, 2019 @12:57PM (#21378799)
I think you are on to something RE using dealership cars as high-end rentals.

I use DriveFlow, which is a Car as a Service. It is owned by a dealership chain.

It is $1100/mo. I love it.

https://www.driveflow.com/

Re:Launch HN: Carve (YC S19) – Rent Cars from Local Dealerships by Loughla on Monday October 28, 2019 @01:22PM (#21379167)
>$1100/mo.

Holy crap, really? How much do you use it to justify that high of a cost? My car, and this number is going down monthly because I paid for it in one lump and it's getting older every month, only costs me $416/mo with maintenance and fuel. I suppose it saves on storage, but I already had a place to store said car, so that's not really an added cost?

Edited to reflect an accurate number after I realized I double entered insurance in fuellog for a year.

Re:Launch HN: Carve (YC S19) – Rent Cars from Local Dealerships by GhettoMaestro on Monday October 28, 2019 @03:20PM (#21380517)
Yeah, so for $1100/mo I get:

- Insurance (1K deductible)

- Unlimited vehicle swaps

- 1200 miles/mo

- Each car comes freshly detailed and is usually under 3000 miles

- Unlimited (local) roadside assistance swaps - eg if I get a flat tire they will come swap me out into another car and I just drive away - this happened to my wife and it was amazing to just grab and go

- Allowed to put pets in the car (extra $100/mo)

As I have customers I drive around in-town frequently, I always need to have a nice, modern, clean car on short notice. The cars so far have been BMW m240i, Audi S3/S4, Audi Q5, Land Rover Discovery.

I feel it is worth the cost. My BMW lease before this was $700/mo. And then add in insurance, detailing, maintenance (tires). It is about the same honestly. I just have a lot more flexibility now.

Also it is a monthly operating expense, which makes the tax situation a lot easier (versus lease/purchase and then reflecting that on taxes).

Re:Launch HN: Carve (YC S19) – Rent Cars from Local Dealerships by quickthrower2 on Monday October 28, 2019 @01:27PM (#21379229)
Depreciation costs?
Re:Launch HN: Carve (YC S19) – Rent Cars from Local Dealerships by w457uiw4gftyi on Monday October 28, 2019 @02:17PM (#21379870)
I didn't know that DriveFlow exists but it's exactly what I've been looking for in a service to replace car ownership:

-No manufacturer lock-in (different manufacturers excel at different things)

-No maintenance burden

-No long/medium term commitment to a single vehicle (maybe I want a minivan for a long summer roadtrip but not all summer or all year)

... but the cost is truly eye-watering.

I had my first kid last year so I got a more family-friendly car than the little coupe I'd been driving. I struggled to decide between a midsize sedan (cheaper, more fun to drive, easier to park, suitable for 95% of the family's driving tasks) or a larger SUV (generally worse, but suitable for 100% of the family's driving tasks).

This would have solved the dilemma for me ... except I think I could just own a decent midsize sedan AND a decent larger SUV for $900 or more per month.