Re:What does it mean for a machine to “understand”?
by empath75 on Monday October 28, 2019 @07:25AM
(#21375948)
Your neurons don’t understand who carol is either, they’re just automatically responding to stimulus.
Re:What does it mean for a machine to “understand”?
by jfk13 on Monday October 28, 2019 @02:32PM
(#21380039)
But am "I" - my consciousness, my understanding - nothing more than a collection of impulses traveling around a particular network of neurons?
We don't know.
I'd suggest that anyone who purports to give a definitive answer to that is in fact making a leap of faith - in one direction or another.
ISTM there's no more "understanding" involved in this than when I touch the Contacts icon on my screen, then "C", "A", "R", etc until Carol's entry is displayed, and then I touch the Phone icon to initiate a call.
The fact that the interface used was sound-waves that the device recognised as matching the keyword "call" and the contact-list entry "Carol", rather than my finger touching specific areas of the screen, may be a handy feature. Of course it's a triumph of signal processing, fuzzy recognition, etc. But there's no more "understanding" involved than in the touch-screen version of the action, or in typing a command and parameter into a terminal window.