This point I've heard too often and it's one I vehemently disagree with.
Australians need to get over this quarter acre with a 250sqm house nonsense. What's more the government should stop subsidizing it to the degree that they are. It's not simply a question of land but all the infrastructure that goes along with it: water, power, roads, schools, etc.
There is no God-given right to build out rather than up.
But that overlooks the fact that overly complex zoning laws, NIMBYist resistance from residents and the odd spot of outright corruption has basically prevented density from increasing.
Density has its costs too. It's cheaper to extend a sewerage and water network in a greenfield project than it is to dig up and replace it in a densely settled area. It's cheaper to maintain small streets than large streets.
As far as stamp duty goes, IMHO that system needs to be abolished. Property taxes should be applied smoothly rather than transactionally. For one thing, stamp duty reduces the flexibility of the labour market.
Consider: someone owns a house in Sydney worth $1 million. They're offered a job in Perth for, say, $150,000. Now to sell up and buy a new house in Perth they'd need to pay $50,000+ in stamp duty before you even get into agents commissions and whatnot. Why should someone take such a huge initial hit? Unless they didn't have a job where they are or the new job was substantially better, they're best off not moving.
As for stamp duty, the states rely on it too much to give it up.
In my opinion, though, what Australia really needs to do is to develop the infrastructure outside the major cities to persuade people to move out there. Australia can easily accommodate another ten million people, but not if they all want to live in Sydney and Melbourne. Why can't Broome and Mildura and Wagga Wagga have two hundred thousand people?
Take my home town Darwin, for example. It is not destined to be one of the world's great cities because it is poorly positioned. There's buckets of water but due to the flatness of the country it's hard to dam. The harbour is large but shallow. The approaches from East and West are not friendly to bulk shipping.
Sydney, Melbourne, Adelaide, Brisbane and Perth are already hogging the best spots for large cities.
Water supply is the major issue in Australian cities, but this can be solved (see Kalgoorlie) if people put their mind to it. I agree that Australia needs to develop the regional areas more.
The factor with Las Vegas and Phoenix are that they are modern growth cities. You don't need a deepwater port to facilitate growth in a modern city, just a good airport, good road/rail links and good communications infrastructure. You could argue that Phoenix is propelled by retirees and golf players and Las Vegas by gambling - but the reason doesn't matter, just the fact that a city can be sustained does.
To cover myself, refer again to my prefatory remark that I was generalising enormously.
Somewhere like Melbourne though, I think things need to become a little less inner city focused. As in new suburbs are popping up but not a lot of employment is close to them meaning that transportation becomes worse as there are ever increasing numbers of people making long trips to work from the outer suburbs. I've always thought it would make sense to stick another inner city like hub somewhere and put high speed rail or something between them, rather than forever branching out from a central hub.
All good and well, but land releases have not kept up with demand. A supply of cheap money from the US, the mining boom and negative gearing have lead to massive increases in housing prices in the past 10 years. It's not sustainable, IMO.
We in Australia brag about sailing through the GFC, but if inflation breaks out, the Reserve Bank will hike up rates mercilessly and a lot of people won't be able to cover the interest on their $3-500k McMansions.