I truly believe this is an unnecessary leaking of personal information. And I address the browser argument directly in the post, as well as the argument that no one cares.
can you confirm quickly that you are proposing that search engines sanitize/anonymize referrer data, and not that they somehow change the referrer behavior?
that's missing the forest for the trees, i think. while it's true that the browser is what sends the referrer, Google has some say in 1) what the referrer is (ie, what url is sent as the referrer) 2) and what Google itself does with that information once they (Google) have received it.
Google could have a stated policy of discarding or anonymizing referrer data. to my knowledge, they do not (i will gladly be corrected on this). they could also structure their results pages urls in such a way that the search terms are not sent as part of the referrer.
for the record, i think that Gabriel has seriously messed up here. i think he's approached this issue in entirely the wrong way, that he is going to lose a lot of good will over it. however, that Gabriel has done something foolish does not detract from the technical merits of either his search engine, or his argument with regards to search leakage. either they're sound, or they're not.
i don't use duckduckgo (yet?). but his argument with regards to search leakage seems to be sound, even if his ad campaign is not.
I'm having a hard time coming up with a reasonable context in which this statement is true.
I think you're going to lose a lot of goodwill Gabriel.
FWIW, I switched my default search in Firefox to DDG last week, partially as a result of the recent "FUD". It's working well and I've already used it for queries that I would prefer Google didn't associate with my IP address. (I'm not logged in to any Google accounts in Firefox, but I am in Chrome, and I'd expect Google to be able to correlate them).
Let me put it this way: they don't target those ads so precisely by not having any information on you. On the contrary, they have lots of info. How safe and how anonymous that info is, that's up for debate.
I was ready to try duckduckgo if it could give me the results I wanted (Despite the hugely irritating UI and infinite scroll).
But the constant attacking Google seems bad business to me. It IS FUD. Google doesn't track you. Your browser sends a referer header, which it has done since the dawn of time. Who cares?
flagged.
I think you're going to lose a lot of goodwill Gabriel.