I say we agree that yes, a Nobel Prize winner might not be destined to become a world-class CEO or whatever. The place to hold the line is in the value of their contribution.
Perhaps we can spin this potential trap back towards reality. Really, when someone becomes a flawless violinist, or programmer, or chemist, what they have made is a tremendous sacrifice. Being best in the world at those things means letting other parts of your mind lie fallow.
I think I might have been more fun to have dinner with when I was in punk bands and reading more books. By dedicating myself to tech I'm probably making a bigger difference in the world, but at some cost to my well-roundedness.
We should laud the winners of intellectual pursuits for the sacrifice they have made for the rest of us.
Of course, what you refer to is just marketing, which will result in underestimating the utility of having these degrees. The fact remains, however, that it still matters if you're well-educated, and it's still going to be causal when it comes to earning income or influencing your sphere.
All that changes is the value - elite topics will be undervalued, so it will be a great time for those who are intrinsically motivated to enter academia.
The right would be having less success with its "movement" if science had done a better job of policing themselves and staying scientists. Instead, across a wide variety of fields, they've been getting into politics. Now they are beginning to experience the consequences, and frankly, "the right", bogeyman or otherwise, isn't entirely wrong here. We don't need more politicians, we need scientists.
It doesn't count that it's really important!!, like the global warming scientists. It's still scientists in politics, not merely saying what is happening but what we should do about it and when. It doesn't count that you like what the political scientists are saying, it's still scientists in politics.
The big problem is that when science goes head to head with the "politics" of the day then there are problems. Galileo encountered this, as did even Darwin (he elected to withhold publication to avoid many problems). The end result in the short-term is the scientist is ostracized ... the long-term vindicated.
Now maybe you're asking scientists to do the same today. Don't publish papers or offer recommendations if it will ruffle feathers. I'm sure many scientists do this, but frankly I don't think this is a satisfactory answer.
Edit: on re-reading, that sounded way snarkier than I wanted. What I mean is, actually do the exercise of trying to find quotes of scientists playing politics. It's not as easy as you seem to think.
Most of those people aren't scientists.
That said, his position is not that "plain talkin' people who struggle with math and science" should be lauded but that social skills are not skills that can be learned through formal education. His point is that group dynamics, being able to read people and lead people, is a very subtle art that is learned throughout childhood and adolescence and Chua denied her children the opportunities to learn these skills by refusing them sleepovers and plays and such.
His point is actually slightly different than what you are saying, and this subtlety is important. Because while Brooks is on the right, is one of their more astute thinkers. Brooks is actually saying that formal education is easy. Not intellectually challenging, and largely a playground. Lets take some quotes:
"I believe she’s coddling her children. She’s protecting them from the most intellectually demanding activities because she doesn’t understand what’s cognitively difficult and what isn’t."
"these and other social tests impose cognitive demands that blow away any intense tutoring session or a class at Yale. "
"Chua would do better to see the classroom as a cognitive break from the truly arduous tests of childhood"
He's not simply saying that there exist other skills that aren't taught in the classroom and that these ar also important and difficult. He's saying something much stronger. He's saying the things that people like Chua value (math, science, arts, literacy, etc...) are the easy things -- the things not to be valued. They're the things you do when your child needs a break or to be coddled. These are the things of intellectual lightweights.
The hard cognitive work is the stuff you see at the corner store in Smalltown USA. These people don't have college degrees, PhDs, Fields Medals, but they can do the actual intellectual demanding activities, not the stuff "you coddle your children" with.
Again, he is not saying this and you are also leaving out the quote at the end which is:
"I wish she recognized that in some important ways the school cafeteria is more intellectually demanding than the library." Emphasis mine.
Please read this article from him and then come back here.
http://www.nytimes.com/2010/09/10/opinion/10brooks.html?ref=...
He seems to focus on industrial entrepreneurship, a capital-intensive proposition to be sure. I peg Brooks as a "supply-side" kinda guy, so he would probably point to tax cuts as the divining rod of spurring entrepreneurship in that area. Thing is, you can cut taxes all day, but if the bank won't lend you any cash because they're not lending anything much less to your really expensive first-time venture, tax cuts aren't gonna help.
And, VC cash is hard to find in the US unless you're doing software, consumer, web, mobile, or cleantech. If you're in "old line" tech like medical devices or consumer electronics, forget it. Overseas is where to go. Open up shop in Singapore if you're building the better artificial heart.
And even that sentence you quote is completely ambiguous. Is he arguing that they're equally demanding? Or that the important ways that matter the school cafeteria is more demanding than the library or vice-versa? You can't tell from that one sentence. But if you read the whole article you can tell what he actually believes. Read the quotes I have from above that are NOT ambiguous. He clearly states that the library is LESS intellectually demanding. No ambiguity, no qualifier.
Read the article in full then come back here.
Although, I do find the below deliciously ironic:
Finally, there’s the lower class. The problem here is social breakdown. Something like a quarter to a third of American children are living with one or no parents, in chaotic neighborhoods with failing schools.
Many of these children have navigated the most treacherous of social environments. Abuse at home, gangs in the neighborhood, and no teaching at school. You'd think they'd be the intellectual highlights of our country. They're not, because everyone really knows that this is not sufficient, nor effective.
This article by Brooks is really saying two things, and is largely unrelated to his later article:
1) The free market doesn't work. People should forego higher paying jobs and do jobs that better help the country. Almost like a large-scale self-imposed socialism.
2) Businesses can't be bothered to train people that don't have college degrees. There are millions of people in the inner city that have the social skills, but not the book smarts or degrees.
Brooks's should put his money where his mouth is and implore businesses to swoop into Watts and hire the available talent. He won't though, because he doesn't actually believe that this is where the intellectual horsepower is. He thinks its at Harvard and MIT, but he'd like you to believe its in Smalltown USA.
You believe this because he makes claims like this: The free market doesn't work. People should forego higher paying jobs and do jobs that better help the country. Almost like a large-scale self-imposed socialism.
So basically, Brooks is part of the conservative right because he is more or less pushing one of Obama's policy proposals [1]?
[1] They might disagree on whether it should be self imposed or government imposed. http://www.barackobama.com/pdf/NationalServicePlanFactSheet....
Yet at the same time isn't willing to ask businesses to step up to the plate.
In other words, he's all about the subtext. He doesn't really believe that traditional measures of achievement are coginitively less demanding than 14 year old sleepovers, but he'll say that so that you value it less.
He doesn't actually believe in self-selected socialism (he loves free markets), but he'll attack Harvard grads so you value them less.
How would we know? I am not aware of any mass formal education system, state supported or otherwise, that makes more than a very token nod in this direction. The closest analogue I'm aware of is social skills training for people with autism spectrum disorders. I know that works if the participants apply the theory outside the classroom, I've seen it. Hell, it even helps a little if you don't, because your modelling skills get better once you have some idea what's going on.
Your example of skills training for autism is probably the best. There's also the self-help and pick-up/dating coach industries. Every single corporate team-building workshop. Basically all of psychology.
Social skills can certainly be taught through formal education (and programmed into robots, too). They do need to be practiced also, but claiming they're not like other kinds of information is the same baseless anthropocentrism argument the conservatives keep pulling out to deny that people weren't like apes, evolution didn't happen, god exists etc. etc.
The conservative right has started a grassroots movement to make traditional measures of intellect and achievement worthy of less distinction. A PhD? Who cares? Nobel Prize in Chemistry? Chemistry isn't that big of a deal, anyone can do it. Plain talkin' people who struggle with things like math and science -- those are the real intellects. Because being an intellect is being someone who can just relate to the every day man. Everything else is just a "hobby" that is no more worthy of distinction than being good at Call of Duty.
Over 2011 expect a full court press on this. Academia, scholarship, science, math, etc... will all be attacked as not particularly interesting. Plain spoken populism will be the new metric for brilliance and the best this country has to offer.