News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Monty Hall Problem by ivanb on Thursday October 24, 2019 @05:10PM (#21349203)
This is only a paradox due to very poor definition.

"You pick a door, say No. 1, and the host, who knows what's behind the doors, opens another door, say No. 3, which has a goat." Where does it state that the host always opens a door with a goat? From the statement it looks like the goat was accidental. No wonder Paul Erdős got confused by this too. The translation of the paradox to his language could have been even more confusing.

Re:Monty Hall Problem by lqet on Thursday October 24, 2019 @06:37PM (#21349908)
100% this.

The first time I read about this problem, it was formulated in a way which made it clear that the host opens a door with a goat behind it. If you learn about it like this, you literally cannot believe how anyone (even Paul Erdős) could believe that switching is not better. After all, you choose a door with a goat behind it with probability 2/3 on your first try, and if you do this, than switching will always win you the car. It is so trivial that the only "paradox" here is that it is classified as a paradox.

E: the explanation on Wikipedia is unnecessarily elaborate and hard to follow:

"The given probabilities depend on specific assumptions about how the host and contestant choose their doors. A key insight is that, under these standard conditions, there is more information about doors 2 and 3 that was not available at the beginning of the game, when door 1 was chosen by the player: the host's deliberate action adds value to the door he did not choose to eliminate, but not to the one chosen by the contestant originally. Another insight is that switching doors is a different action than choosing between the two remaining doors at random, as the first action uses the previous information and the latter does not. Other possible behaviors than the one described can reveal different additional information, or none at all, and yield different probabilities. "

What?

Re:Monty Hall Problem by henrikschroder on Thursday October 24, 2019 @10:14PM (#21351207)
There are plenty of people who keep getting tripped up by this problem even when it's correctly formulated. Statistics and probabilities are sometimes incredibly unintuitive and hard for a lot of people.

I only took a single class of statistics at university, but my biggest take-away from that class is that you absolutely cannot trust your gut, because the human bias is crazy strong.

Re:Monty Hall Problem by will4274 on Friday October 25, 2019 @01:10AM (#21352089)
Disagree.

Humans naturally over-connect. We see causation where only correlation is present. Gamblers believe that something random that has happened frequently (like roulette landing on a specific number) is more likely to happen again. Educated people learn about dependent and independent probability, which corrects this impulse. But sometimes it over-corrects.

The Monty Hall problem is hard because people see can't explain the dependent probability link clearly and conclude that the probabilities are independent and their brain is acting up - first guess 1 in 3, second guess 1 in 2. After all, the game host is always capable of opening a door with a goat, and the player doesn't know anything. Put differently, what did the player learn between the first and the second guess that should make the player now believe one door is more likely than the other of the remaining two?

It also takes advantage of our natural thinking. The problem is artificial, because, outside of a game show, the host could also just not offer to switch. Emotional then, brains consider the information that the host made the second offer even if it's not logically part of the problem.

Re:Monty Hall Problem by dboreham on Thursday October 24, 2019 @09:00PM (#21350794)
Funny, because that's essentially what I said above, hoping to help folks understand ;) (I didn't write the wikipedia article..)
Re:Monty Hall Problem by 0x5345414e on Thursday October 24, 2019 @05:13PM (#21349243)
Exactly. It made perfect sense to me once I realized that the host knows where the prize is and thus is giving you information by opening a door.
Re:Monty Hall Problem by kangnkodos on Thursday October 24, 2019 @05:25PM (#21349359)
Yes. If the host's algorithm is to pick a door randomly, then your odds change. In this other scenario, your odds do not improve by switching.

If the problem does not state what the host's algorithm is, and you have no knowledge of the host's algorithm (example: you have never seen the TV show before), then the logical action is to assume the host chooses a door to reveal randomly.

Re:Monty Hall Problem by Kiro on Friday October 25, 2019 @02:08AM (#21352322)
> If the host's algorithm is to pick a door randomly, then your odds change. In this other scenario, your odds do not improve by switching.

Isn't it the other way round?

Re:Monty Hall Problem by elihu on Thursday October 24, 2019 @05:41PM (#21349489)
You also have to trust the host to behave fairly. For instance, a malicious host might decide to open a door with a goat only when your first choice was correct. If the rules of the game are such that the host must always open a door with a goat regardless of whether your first guess was right or wrong, then it makes sense to switch doors. If not, it might be a trap; probably the best strategy is just to flip a coin.
Re:Monty Hall Problem by twiceaday on Thursday October 24, 2019 @05:33PM (#21349426)
I don't think you are correct. The host does not give you any useful information by opening a goat door. Opening a goat door only serves to confuse you into not realizing that the switch-choice is actually between one of the doors and a grouping of the remaining two doors. Opening a goat door in the grouping of the other two only changes the groups appearance, making it look like the single door that you picked. It does not change the functional state of that group in terms of its probability of containing a car.
Re:Monty Hall Problem by 0x5345414e on Friday October 25, 2019 @12:27AM (#21351881)
It doesn't change the state of the group of the two remaining doors, correct (ie. the probability remains at 2/3). But you can't choose two doors, you can only choose one. The host is effectively telling you which door to switch to--the one he didn't pick.

The only scenario in which the host doesn't give you any useful information by opening a door is when the host chooses the door at random. Assuming the host didn't choose the door with the prize, your odds are 50:50.

Of course all of this hinges on you being aware of the host's decision making paradigm, and that you want a car more than you want a goat.

Re:Monty Hall Problem by twiceaday on Friday October 25, 2019 @01:15AM (#21352110)
I'm not sure what your point is. Assuming the host always opens a goat door, you can simply restate the problem as being allowed to pick two doors at the same time. You are literally choosing two doors, because if the car was behind the first he would have opened the second, and if the car was behind the second he would have opened the first. It would have looked like you are switching to one other door but you can simply look at it as switching to the other two doors, where the elimination of the dud door can be done before or after.
Re:Monty Hall Problem by zeendo on Thursday October 24, 2019 @05:46PM (#21349529)
I love discussing the Monty Hall problem with people who haven't been exposed to it before. I always make it clear that the host knows what's behind each door and will open a door with a goat. People still, most of the time, get the answer wrong.
Re:Monty Hall Problem by lotsofpulp on Thursday October 24, 2019 @07:57PM (#21350408)
Yes, the question is best phrased as “should the contestant change their choice of doors”.
Re:Monty Hall Problem by Kiro on Friday October 25, 2019 @02:09AM (#21352331)
How does that make anything clearer?
Re:Monty Hall Problem by moosinho on Thursday October 24, 2019 @07:59PM (#21350418)
I wouldn't say that's the core of the paradox. The thing is that people don't have a good understanding what probability is. We think that when we choose a gate at the beginning, with a chance of winning being 1/3 it means that the universe "rolls" a dice and decides whether we win or not. It is then very confusing to realize that someone else, just by revealing the content of one of the other gates - after our decision has been made - can somehow make the universe roll a different dice with 2/3 odds.

The paradox disappears when you think about probability as a tool for reasoning from incomplete information, not as anything to do with "physical" property of the system under investigation. It then makes perfect sense that after receiving new information from the host we should reassign our probabilities.