This guy wasn't traveling, and therefore had zero legal requirement to produce ID.
By your own metric, he required ID, because he drove to the border patrol station.
Which he knew he needed his ID for, because he had done so many times before.
The point I am making is simply that it is not so surprising to me that when things go outside of the normal process, things may go sideways when dealing with potentially hostile government agents.
In the 100 mile zone, they definitely have to have a defensible "reasonable suspicion" of criminal activity before they can stop & search someone.
Edit: Ha! The truth, as ever, ain't too popular.
This article mentions an instance where they colluded with local LE to harass citizens near a marijuana festival. Also deportable arrests are abysmally low, whereas their drug related arrests are absurdly high. It really sounds like they're a branch of DEA.
On the other hand, I think the headline and the tone of the article definitely want me to judge this as "bad" on the part of the border patrol. Indeed, I strongly believe in personal privacy and due process.
However, there is a fact buried in the article that makes this a non-routine pickup indeed:
"""He was asked for his identification in order to pay the small duty fee for his daughter’s gifts, and only then realized that he’d left his wallet at home. When he explained this, that he’d made an honest mistake and wanted only to pay the routine duty owed and depart, he was told that in fact he wasn’t permitted to leave."""
So again, I agree in general that the privacy protections afforded to U.S. citizens are very important; but, I am not so surprised after reading this that things went sideways.
It seems to me, many government agencies and employees are used to things going a certain way, and as soon as something unexpected happens, they clamp down and things can get a lot more serious.
A few years ago I was flying domestically between two states, and the fancy bomb detection thing flagged me. Of course, I wasn't carrying anything remotely explosive. Nonetheless, I was taken to a back room with a supervisor and two regular homeland security agents. I was told this time they would search my bag and scan me again. If it came back negative, I would be free to go. If it came back positive, they would conduct a strip search. Thankfully, it came back negative.
I nearly missed my flight, it was incredibly terrifying in the moment, but I didn't feel like my rights were violated. According to the agents, the most likely cause was that I had used hand sanitizer prior to getting in the security line.
Back to the article -- personally, I'm very interested in the results of the court proceedings, but unclear how to keep track of them.