Re:Hacker Shows It Doesn’t Take $8 Million to Clone Qwiki
by StavrosK on Sunday January 23, 2011 @01:06PM
(#2132930)
Not to sound snarky, but I liked this sentence:
> I'd wager good money that if you gave a random sample of 1000 people the option of either reading a wikipedia page or watching a qwiki, a majority would choose qwiki. If that's not proof that they are solving a problem differently, than we'll just have agree to disagree.
It basically says, "I think Qwiki is solving a problem, and if you don't find my opinion proof enough, then we just can't agree on it."
Re:Hacker Shows It Doesn’t Take $8 Million to Clone Qwiki
by melvinram on Sunday January 23, 2011 @02:00PM
(#2133041)
I agree that it's not the most elegant way to state what I was saying. What I meant to say was:
I'd wager good money that if you gave a random sample of 1000 people the option of either reading a wikipedia page or watching a qwiki, a majority would choose qwiki. If you don't think that assumption is a safe assumption, than we'll just have agree to disagree.
Re:Hacker Shows It Doesn’t Take $8 Million to Clone Qwiki
by mike-cardwell on Sunday January 23, 2011 @05:59PM
(#2133580)
I'd wager the opposite. People looking up information like to scan well presented text, not watch a slide show.
Re:Hacker Shows It Doesn’t Take $8 Million to Clone Qwiki
by dstein on Sunday January 23, 2011 @12:40PM
(#2132867)
Just because you use technology doesn't mean you're inventing it.
Very few startups would qualify as truly innovative, and disruptive:
Re:Hacker Shows It Doesn’t Take $8 Million to Clone Qwiki
by wippler on Sunday January 23, 2011 @12:46PM
(#2132882)
Also in that sample of 1000 people the people who chose Wikipedia will have better understanding on their subject rather than the disjoint pieces spitted out by Qwiki.
Re:Hacker Shows It Doesn’t Take $8 Million to Clone Qwiki
by alain94040 on Sunday January 23, 2011 @01:15PM
(#2132950)
Great. You just proved that TV has no commercial potential :-)
Technology - the practical application of science to commerce or industry
Looks to me like they have applied the knowledge of Text-to-Speech, audio/video playback, content curation, etc. to the practical problem of communicating information.
Innovation is not only doing something new but also using existing knowledge and tools to solve a problem differently.
I'd wager good money that if you gave a random sample of 1000 people the option of either reading a wikipedia page or watching a qwiki, a majority would choose qwiki. If that's not proof that they are solving a problem differently, than we'll just have agree to disagree.