News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The IRS Targets Income Tricks by patio11 on Sunday January 23, 2011 @11:48AM (#2132720)
Small businesses are somewhat notorious for aggressively interpreting the tax code in one's favor, largely because they have a variety of options for doing so not available to the W-2 employee. The game theory sort of incentivizes it, too: heads you save 100% of the taxes at issue, tails you have to pay the taxes at issue and (if you had any sort of a good faith case) only interest at a below-market rate on them... and the coin is known to flip tails only a few percentage points of the time, due to how infrequent audits are.

This is complicated by the fact that, if the tax code were a spec, it would have some requirements which were contradictory and very many interactions whose behavior was totally undefined.

For example, BCC has a fairly similar issue: if the profits are earned income received for the value of my services as an engineer/etc, then they're subject to a generous exclusion since I was physically in Japan when I earned them (foreign earned income exemption, form 2555). If they're unearned income -- that is, if the business is generating profits above the fair market value of the time I am investing -- then they are not subject to that exclusion and I owe the IRS a few thousand extra. On a separate axis, they may not be attributable to the business at all, but as a result of sale of real property, depending on whether the computer software counts as personal property or not, which apparently turns on the degree of support/customization I offer and the mood of the examining IRS clerk. If they aren't attributable to the business and are a sale of real property, then they are excludable, as long as the transaction is not sourced to the United States. Sales of real property are sourced where the transaction physically takes place... but the IRS literally has no opinion on where that is for sales of downloadable software. (I asked. They said "Write up your reasoning with your tax form. If we don't bill you, you're good.") If they are not real property, they may be a sale of computer licenses, which are arguably a source of royalties, which could be subject to a US/Japan tax treaty provision which overrides some of these rules but not others.

The above is not tax advice. Don't even ask about the Japanese side -- I have a few more weeks to figure that mind-meltingness yet.

Re:The IRS Targets Income Tricks by rubyrescue on Sunday January 23, 2011 @05:00PM (#2133451)
i just realized the both of us need to start an american-expat-tech-entrepreneur-tax forum. a few other people are in the same boat and email me based on my profile from time to time. I find i know much more about IRS tax code regarding form 2555 than most US accountants because they just don't deal with it much, OR, the ones that have charge way more than I can afford to help me with my questions - but i haven't found a place to discuss these type of issues online. perhaps a google group?
Re:The IRS Targets Income Tricks by camz on Sunday January 23, 2011 @11:47PM (#2134279)
I'd be willing to help with my experience with these tax issues. =)

I'm both licensed and experienced in the tax field.

Re:The IRS Targets Income Tricks by po on Sunday January 23, 2011 @06:03PM (#2133592)
Please do. I would join it in a heart beat.
Re:The IRS Targets Income Tricks by khafra on Monday January 24, 2011 @11:22AM (#2135545)
There doesn't seem to be a tax.stackexchange.com yet.
Re:The IRS Targets Income Tricks by hnl2sea2nrt on Sunday January 23, 2011 @09:15PM (#2133979)
I would join as well. Very complicated issue without much affordable help available.
Re:The IRS Targets Income Tricks by jhancock on Sunday January 23, 2011 @07:33PM (#2133787)
Your position is certainly how things have been for the last 15 years or so. Recently, the IRS is more apt to provide penalties and pretty high interest for perceived underpayment and its your task to prove "good faith" after you've coughed up the fees. This can get costly. Additionally, the IRS doubled its auditors in 2010. Best to ensure your 2555 exemption stays tight as there are few other rocks to hide under these days for anyone but the very wealthy.