News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Ranked-choice voting is on the ballot in New York City by davidw on Tuesday October 22, 2019 @02:06PM (#21326814)
Seems good, but perhaps a bit difficult to explain to the average voter?
Re:Ranked-choice voting is on the ballot in New York City by tunesmith on Tuesday October 22, 2019 @02:18PM (#21326942)
Condorcet isn't particularly hard to explain. Easier to explain than IRV anyway. Call it "Instant Round Robin" - if one candidate would beat every other candidate head-to-head, then that candidate should win.

The annoying part about Condorcet enthusiasts is that they insist on lumping the uncommon "tie-breaking" methods (i.e. when there is the rare loop) in with the above general definition. That's when people start talking about Schulz, Ranked-Pairs, etc etc. I personally think a loop is valuable and shouldn't be tie-breaked - it's an indication that the voters are not ready to decide and that there should be another round of debate among the finalists before revoting.

In my opinion, the main flaw with Condorcet is that it is possible to have a Condorcet Winner that does not have the "approval" of a majority of voters.

Re:Ranked-choice voting is on the ballot in New York City by smeyer on Tuesday October 22, 2019 @04:38PM (#21328265)
>another round of debate among the finalists before revoting

What do you do if revoting doesn't break the deadlock? Also, just in general, I think a lot of people don't want a system that involves potential revoting.

Re:Ranked-choice voting is on the ballot in New York City by mjevans on Tuesday October 22, 2019 @06:28PM (#21329090)
You get the current BRexit situation, and we'll hopefully soon see some kind of historical test case the refer to...
Re:Ranked-choice voting is on the ballot in New York City by flukus on Tuesday October 22, 2019 @07:11PM (#21329405)
> Call it "Instant Round Robin" - if one candidate would beat every other candidate head-to-head, then that candidate should win.

And 90% of peoples eyes just glazed over, all to fix some almost entirely theoretical flaws with IRV, that's why condorcet isn't better in the real world.

Re:Ranked-choice voting is on the ballot in New York City by tunesmith on Tuesday October 22, 2019 @07:27PM (#21329519)
90% of which people, the people that are enamored by "count up all first place votes, then find the person in last place, then go look at everyone's ballots and remove that person from everyone's ballots, and then count up all first place votes again, and then repeat that process until you're left with one person and then that candidate should win"?
Re:Ranked-choice voting is on the ballot in New York City by flukus on Tuesday October 22, 2019 @07:40PM (#21329615)
If you're number 1 choice is knocked out you're vote goes to you're number 2 choice, if they're knocked out it goes to number 3... It's not about understanding the intricacies of how the count works but understanding what their individual vote will be doing. When it comes to what you're individual vote is doing Condorcet is much more of a black box.