News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:A Landmark Climate Trial Turns on Whether Exxon Cooked th... by travisoneill1 on Tuesday October 22, 2019 @12:06PM (#21325289)
It's 50 years later and we still don't have a carbon tax even though everyone has known about global warming basically the whole time and much more comprehensive research than Exxon ever did is now public domain. There is about a 0% chance this would have been different if Exxon had released its research.
Re:A Landmark Climate Trial Turns on Whether Exxon Cooked th... by NeedMoreTea on Tuesday October 22, 2019 @12:23PM (#21325508)
Well. If they had released their research and not thrown container loads of money at denialist lobby groups and think tanks, I think it could have been different. Perhaps all those US Republican politicians who used to accept climate change before George HW Bush was elected would still be convinced. Exxon brag about the billions in Arctic drilling rights they secure from Russia after they bloody melted it enough. Maybe they should have released research with a plan to pivot to mostly not oil.

BP and Exxon annoy me particularly. They paint themselves so damn eco-friendly in ads, but chuck blank cheques at those working against eco-sustainability and carbon reduction.

Hopefully the next generation find a way to prosecute when they get into positions of influence and power.

Greenpeace, but the timeline is right:

[1] https://www.greenpeace.org/usa/global-warming/exxon-and-the-...

Re:A Landmark Climate Trial Turns on Whether Exxon Cooked th... by dontreact on Tuesday October 22, 2019 @12:09PM (#21325324)
The point is that if Exxon went public with these findings (and in general was more honest about climate change sooner) it would be harder for them and others to lobby politicians against a carbon tax.

Even though the science is clear, nearly every republican congressperson on the relevant committees doubts that humans are the main driver of climate change which is pretty necessary belief if you want to put in a carbon tax.

This same type of argument applies to the large subsidies that exist to this day. It would have been politically much harder to secure subsidies of the magnitude that exist today if they too had research out that supported the scientific consensus.

Re:A Landmark Climate Trial Turns on Whether Exxon Cooked th... by travisoneill1 on Tuesday October 22, 2019 @12:13PM (#21325369)
The political hurdle to a carbon tax has nothing to do with Exxon's lobbyists. Politicians are scared shitless of raising gas prices. When France tried to do it recently it caused massive riots.
Re:A Landmark Climate Trial Turns on Whether Exxon Cooked th... by dontreact on Tuesday October 22, 2019 @12:18PM (#21325443)
Are you really going to claim that the fossil fuel industry’s massive lobbying effort has had no impact on fossil fuel subsidies or taxing carbon? You think it’s entirely due to gas prices?

If you or anyone could prove this, they would be in a position to save the fossil fuel industry massive amounts of money (and therefore probably also figure out a way to get a cut of that).

Re:A Landmark Climate Trial Turns on Whether Exxon Cooked th... by vkou on Tuesday October 22, 2019 @12:18PM (#21325437)
French riots were caused by a large number of things, but the pro-global warming lobby managed to focus public anger on the carbon tax, instead of all the other causes for their economic woes.

Mailing each man, woman, and child two equal cheques, with the words 'CARBON PROPSPERITY TAX', one at Christmas, and one at Thanksgiving would very quickly turn public opinion towards a carbon tax.

Re:A Landmark Climate Trial Turns on Whether Exxon Cooked th... by jfengel on Tuesday October 22, 2019 @02:10PM (#21326849)
It wouldn't be as easy as that. A carbon tax will result in higher prices of a lot of goods, including food: anything that has to be shipped has some carbon built into the price, and farming uses a lot of oil-fuelled machines. It wouldn't necessarily be a large increase, but it would make a potent talking point against it. Even if you got it passed, they would see prices rise before the "carbon prosperity check" arrived.

It's a good idea even though there are more difficulties than I mentioned. But it's not an easy sell.

Re:A Landmark Climate Trial Turns on Whether Exxon Cooked th... by dontreact on Tuesday October 22, 2019 @12:28PM (#21325573)
This is brilliant. A progressive enough government could even give people “a free trial” of a carbon tax by having this part of it kick in a few months before the tax starts, with the check explaining what the money was coming from.