News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Are Liberal Arts Colleges Doomed? by ydnaclementine on Monday October 21, 2019 @11:26PM (#21320127)
To me, part of the problem is the supply of colleges. There's so many of them! Every state has their big state schools, and their smaller, private, low acceptance rate "institutions". But then there's a billion small schools that no one has every heard of, and I'm not sure who is even going there. But I may be biased and don't understand having gone to a big state school.

Maybe they were created to fill demand that is now drying up. But if you search for any US state like: "Ohio colleges", google will show you "100+ more colleges" for majority of states.

Re:Are Liberal Arts Colleges Doomed? by ineedasername on Monday October 21, 2019 @11:55PM (#21320242)
In terms of a full college enrollment scenario, i.e., everyone goes to college, there wouldn't be enough supply. About 70% of HS grads start college, and considering many stop out along the way, we're way off from college having the sort of enrollment that High School has. However, enrollment has been increasing steadily. The rate at which students attend college has increased about 10% since 2000. In that sense, as long as we don't add to the inventory of colleges, gradual enrollment growth will fill the ranks of existing colleges.

However, the above assumes that the value proposition of college in society doesn't significantly change. There are pointers that it is. Although the problem is there isn't any alternative ready for it to switch to en mass. If people doubt the value proposition today, they're left with not going at all, which is a worse value proposition, or looking at something like a trade school-- that's a perfectly reasonable option, but issues of social perception/prestige make it less attractive, and many trades have low salary caps. A "medical assistant" tops out around $45k for example, though the more rigorous "physicians assistant" can pay up to double that. But overall, trades are fairly likely to have a firm ceiling on wages. Not that graduating college as an English major is always going to pay more, it's just that there's less of a ceiling baked in to it. (Though I'd argue the floor is much lower, like $10/hour barista low)

Re:Are Liberal Arts Colleges Doomed? by secabeen on Tuesday October 22, 2019 @12:07AM (#21320296)
The other challenge with the trades is that they are more subject to the boom and bust cycles than the jobs that a liberal-arts degree qualifies you for. When construction is hot, it's hot, but when the market turns, a lot of those companies that were employing 20 electricians drop to just 5-7. That's less common in social work, law/medicine, government and non-profit, etc.
Re:Are Liberal Arts Colleges Doomed? by Scoundreller on Tuesday October 22, 2019 @03:57AM (#21321248)
In other words, some jobs are stocks, others are bonds.

A lot of the “bond” jobs are overvalued. Being able to earn when everyone else can’t has its benefits.

Re:Are Liberal Arts Colleges Doomed? by wideasleep1 on Tuesday October 22, 2019 @12:23AM (#21320361)
I think it is trade-dependent. Certainly a good welder will weather cycles better than a finish carpenter.
Re:Are Liberal Arts Colleges Doomed? by droithomme on Tuesday October 22, 2019 @12:05AM (#21320285)
> $10/hour barista low

That's pretty darn low given that the cities hipster enough to have a barista career track tend to have the $15/hr minimum wage.

Re:Are Liberal Arts Colleges Doomed? by catalogia on Tuesday October 22, 2019 @12:15AM (#21320333)
"Barista" is a job title in damn near every small town across America. Any big enough to have a starbucks at least.
Re:Are Liberal Arts Colleges Doomed? by ineedasername on Thursday October 24, 2019 @04:59PM (#21349093)
And in cities like that, $15 an hour goes about as far as $10 in a more suburban area with a lower cost of living. I mean, I could have said "COL adjusted minimum wage", but I think the point was fairly clear.
Re:Are Liberal Arts Colleges Doomed? by OldHand2018 on Monday October 21, 2019 @11:47PM (#21320218)
Ohio is an interesting case. Any "high school" student that can't get an appropriately difficult class at their local school can take the class at a nearby college for both high school and college credit simultaneously. It is paid for by the state of Ohio.

It is obviously a really good thing for smart students in small towns and rural school districts and probably a big reason Ohio has a lot of small colleges, though in recent years Ohio has allocated a pool of money to pay for it all and when it runs out (it always runs out), then you have to pay for the classes yourself.

Re:Are Liberal Arts Colleges Doomed? by catalogia on Monday October 21, 2019 @11:57PM (#21320253)
Is that unusual? I've heard of other states having similar programs. When I was a teenager in Pennsylvania, my time during the school day was split between highschool and community college (paid for by the state or school district, I don't recall.

It's a good system, though few bothered to take advantage of it. I was one of 4 or 5 kids in my grade that took advantage of the system, even though there were dozens of better students than me who doubtlessly qualified.

Re:Are Liberal Arts Colleges Doomed? by OldHand2018 on Tuesday October 22, 2019 @12:05AM (#21320283)
I'm not from Ohio; where I grew up if such a program existed I didn't know about it. But I also attended a high school with almost 3000 students that had a very large selection of courses.
Re:Are Liberal Arts Colleges Doomed? by ineedasername on Tuesday October 22, 2019 @12:01AM (#21320269)
High Schools & colleges near me partner for this sort of thing, though I don't think there's a lot of state funding to support it. It's unfortunate, since data generally shows that students who get a head start in that way are much more likely to graduate.
Re:Are Liberal Arts Colleges Doomed? by kevindong on Tuesday October 22, 2019 @12:15AM (#21320336)
There's a very strong correlation between students who sign up for those kinds of classes and who would've otherwise gone onto the college pathway anyway.
Re:Are Liberal Arts Colleges Doomed? by ineedasername on Tuesday October 22, 2019 @09:34AM (#21323400)
Yes, but there's also a strong correlation for students who are forced into those courses due to mandatory "bridge" programs for under-prepared students. Source:I work in higher education analytics