I never understand why people ask questions like this. Just a raw, but likely inflammatory, question with no additional exposition explaining what it is they really want to know. In reality, without defining the parameters of what would constitute "success" or "failure" there is no real answer to this question, except a bunch of people's opinions.

So 30 or 40 people say "yes", 30 or 40 more say "no" and what new, actionable insight does anybody gain from this?