News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Do It Yourself Masters in Financial Engineering by nightski on Saturday January 22, 2011 @04:09PM (#2131082)
Wow, and you actually find these books valuable? Any book I read that I truly learn something from usually takes weeks or months to get through. Call me slow but it just takes time for real information to sink in for me. Sure I understand the words, but to fully absorb the knowledge takes time. Reading 200-400 books a year - how do you ever get the chance to absorb any of that information? If you can really learn valuable information from a book in 10-20 minutes than I am jealous.

Maybe business books are just different than technical/science oriented ones.

Re:Do It Yourself Masters in Financial Engineering by joshkaufman on Saturday January 22, 2011 @05:10PM (#2131203)
Business texts and technical books are very different. I read math/science/programming books as well - I'm currently working through Probability Theory: The Logic of Science by E.T. Jaynes. There's no way I could grok that book in 20 minutes.

10-20 minutes won't cut it for deep technical material, particularly if the book is designed to teach via working through examples. If you're reading a workbook, then take the time to work through the examples. Choose your workbooks carefully, since they require a more significant time investment.

Most non-fiction books, however, are written around a few simple, straightforward concepts - you can identify them in a few minutes. A few more minutes identifying examples, relationships to other concepts, and counter-examples / edge cases, and you've extracted 90% of the value of the text.

Almost every non-fiction book fits this model. It pays to tailor your reading approach to what you're reading.

As to value - in general, most business books are marginally valuable in isolation. Once you read many of them, however, very useful patterns begin to emerge. Recognizing and using those patterns provides the value.

Re:Do It Yourself Masters in Financial Engineering by crasshopper on Sunday January 23, 2011 @04:48AM (#2132140)
On the other hand, the more you get used to reading math, the more possible it becomes for your eye to skim through math stuff.

I'm at the point where I can sometimes skim through arXiv papers and understand the gist.

(Does it work the same for books with code in them? Legit coders can skim and understand?)

Re:Do It Yourself Masters in Financial Engineering by AlexC04 on Sunday January 23, 2011 @08:06AM (#2132343)
The short answer: Syntax Error. -- I spend a lot of time working with different languages and frameworks. Though my day job is PHP, I've got an itch to make a mobile game.

Since they're not actually written in PHP, I've got to switch to a new language. ObjectiveC for iPhone, Android-Java, or any number of cross platform languages to pick up a third party framework.

On top of that - there's the issues of structure and stuff.

For learning a new language, there's no way to skim.

HOWEVER for something like an A* pathfinding algorythm (an artificial intelligence method of finding the most efficient path from A to Anywhere) - you can get the "Gist" by skimming a paper. I understand what A* is and how it does it ... but if I want to replicate it I still have to go over it line-by-line if I want to get it right though.

So, I think the short answer is "NO" coders can't skim stuff and get the job done right.