Might have something to do with unconscious straining of the eyes. Diagnosis based on hearsay - my friend had this problem and it vanished after he switched from a closed-eyed to open-eyed technique.
Recently I started again with a teacher and it is awesome. It makes all the good bits great and minimizes all the unpleasant stuff.
There is a dude called Alan Chapman, who has a great deal of experience with meditation and dream states. In addition to this he reads Wired and is down to earth.
First you need to learn to focus your mind, you take a bright object (a firelighter works great) and you stare into the flame. Then you slowly and carefully shut down your brain and just focus on the bright light. If a tought pops up the most important thing to remember is to let it go and focus away from it, if you get mad or focusing on not focusing on it that's one more tought that popped up.
Then once you get the hang of that you can start doing more interesting things. My favourite was to attempt super-position and out of body experiences. Basically you sit in a comfortable position and focus on a memory of a place, or a made-up place. You slowly build up the image of your surroundings, starting with what's immediately before your eyes and then going from there. Once you're proficient in building a visual representation of fake surroundings you start with sounds, smells and tastes. When you get that down you can start fooling your kinestatic sense, which means you have to feel your arms/legs/body in a different position than it actually is.
Once you've done that, voila, you've just achieved lucid REM at will.
If you talk to a spirituality guru they will tell you it's an astral plane, or out of body experience. But really it's just lucid REM :)
I never managed to quite completely detach myself from reality, I got into the super-position state where I could feel myself being in two places at once ... sort of everywhere.
The main thing you have to remember when doing any of these experiments is that your mind is the only thing in the world fully under your control. It cannot do something you don't let it do.
Most actively I was going after clairvoyance.
And it worked to an extent, I eventually stopped because I couldn't distinguish what my mind was thinking it was doing from any sort of actual physical effect and I never managed to achieve anything that couldn't adequately be explained as lucid REM.
To me your method is more likely to induce WILD not OBE. And I don't think it's the same. Edit: visualization and the fact you seeked clairvoyance could be an explanation for your constant headache, I suppose your sixth chakra was very active?
There were three main effects I personally got from meditation:
1. A constant headache that lasted a few years and then promptly ended when I stopped meditating. Of course this could just be correlation, but it's one hell of correlation.
2. From my later experiences I found out that meditating that often and on that level (I could go into lucid REM within a minute of concentrating and then snap myself out of it at will) had a similar effect as constantly being on light doses of hallucinogenic drugs. It was really quite awesome, everything had a deep richness to it, colours were brighter, shapes were more pronounced etc.
3. Daily meditation also produced some quite interesting side-effects like being able to hold my breath for several minutes and reducing my heart rate to 40bpm (measured with an at-home cardiograph).
Another interesting effect of being able to go into REM at will was that I could live for a few years on 4 hours of daily sleep because I was in effect doing polyphasic sleep.
The only prolonged effect from meditation that I can still notice three-ish years after stopping is that I no longer dream like a normal person.
Maybe I should start meditating again, that stuff was kinda fun.