Re:A Dumb TV for Consumers
by tyingq on Sunday October 20, 2019 @11:30AM
(#21304726)
If it's not less expensive than a smart TV, I'll continue buying smart TVs and just not configuring them. A smart TV makes a perfectly good dumb one. Just plug my Roku into the HDMI port. Newer Rokus come with tv power/volume buttons, so I don't touch the TV remote again.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
This was my position, but now I like having a TCL Roku TV. The HDMI inputs are channels on the app screen, but all my tv settings are in the roku interface. It eliminates having that additional layer of settings between the two devices like frame rate and passthrough/bitstream audio. It eliminates having two user interface layers (the tv and the box) to change settings on. I have way more sound problems passing arc from a streaming box to a soundbar, through a tv intermediate, than I do from a smart tv to a soundbar. (FireCube+Vizio M Series is a disaster. The audio cuts out every 3rd time alexa triggers or you pause.) I can still have an apple tv and fire stick plugged in, but TCL and Roku have done a great job of treating the tvs as first class Roku citizens. It's nothing like Android and the OEM getting in the way of updates. They also arent underpowering the internal roku, its an ultra not a budget roku.
I still don't like Smart TVs and it's not because it has a built-in Roku or whatever. We purchased a Roku TV that I really liked initially, however over the past couple of months I've noticed that the volume takes forever to change. Like it lags a couple of seconds after I've last pressed the button and sometimes I have to compensate because I've over corrected. sigh In the past week I've noticed that I can't fast-forward through Netflix or YouTube videos any more. I hold down the button and the light flashes on the the TV but nothing happens.
Ultimately, I want a dumb TV that does nothing but turn on and adjust the volume. This TV looks pretty good for me but I think it might be a bit too simple. I don't really want to hang it on the wall and it would be nice to have speakers built-in, at least so I can listen to videos before I splurge on an external speaker box.
Is there a substantive difference between something like the cheapo TCL with integrated Roku and a dumb / unconfigured smart TV with an external Roku?
Genuine question—I mean, is TCL+Roku likely to share different telemetry due to manufacturer requirements or pricing constraints?