Re:Superfast Nike shoes are creating a problem
by jjeaff on Sunday October 20, 2019 @04:31PM
(#21306892)
>So F1s could average 300mph on an identical track if it were nothing like the existing track. Gotcha.
That's not how I read it. He said 90 degrees to the -outside-. Which would be significantly more difficult than the current track and seemingly impossible until you consider that the air downforce would need to overpower the centrifugal force lifting them away from the track.
But perhaps 90 degrees to the outside doesn't mean what I think it means.
Re:Superfast Nike shoes are creating a problem
by lakisy on Monday October 21, 2019 @01:46PM
(#21315093)
A Formula 1 car can drive upside down .
https://uk.sports.yahoo.com/news/can-an-f1-car-drive-on-the-...
Nah, that's an excuse FIA uses because it realised that's how it could put restrictions in place.
If it were solely about safety, FIA would restrict the capabilities of the machines, not their design details.
> I read an article once in which an F1 team's lead engineer claimed that a car with no limitations would average 300 hundred miles per hour around a track that's identical to a current track but turned so all the curves were banked 90 degrees to the outside.
So F1s could average 300mph on an identical track if it were nothing like the existing track. Gotcha.
> Restrictions seem to be tightened in direct response to severe accidents that increase in frequency as engineering advances.
That's really not true. FIA does regularly impose safety features or restrictions (e.g. halo, or wheel tethers) but most of the restrictions have nothing to do with safety.
> It turns out that letting cars get any faster than they are right now doesn't make human skill irrelevant, it just gets people killed.
So… don't do that? If your goal is the safety of the pilot you put limits on the performance characteristics of the car (top speed, acceleration, …). You don't mandate the materials the turbo can be built out of.
> Higher-performance planes would result in victory going to the pilot most willing to die. Which is precisely what we see in air racing: The Red Bull Air Race rules instantly disqualify racers that pull 10g for more than half a second or 12g ever [4].
Right, so for safety reasons RBAR restricts the performance characteristics of competing planes.
FIA does not do that, it restricts the design details of the cars.
I'm not saying it's bad, mind, just that F1 / the FIA has a very limited and restrictive embrace of tech.