Re:When Medical Debt Collectors Decide Who Gets Arrested
by bhupy on Sunday October 20, 2019 @04:41PM
(#21306972)
> Also, one cost of running "laboratories of democracy" is that some of them fail, and some of them are run incompetently or corruptly or cruelly.
That is true of nation states as well, and yet we trust them with sovereignty.
In our Union, states have to abide by a baseline set of rules per the Federal Constitution (free speech, right to a fair trial, equal protection before the law, etc). US States aren’t run by Kings and Queens, they’re democracies with checks and balances, state Constitutions, judiciaries, legislatures, and executive agencies.
Insofar as a state would be run corruptly or cruelly, it would be the will of the people of those states.
It is a complex topic, and the variety of "solutions" to the problem give us a lot to chew on.
I don't personally think that's optimal - there are a number of problems US states have that nation-states don't. (Deficit financing, exclusion and latitude to make its own rules being larger ones.) Also, one cost of running "laboratories of democracy" is that some of them fail, and some of them are run incompetently or corruptly or cruelly.
But if you like the idea of state level fixes, by all means pull for that. There is no single right answer.