I'm not saying they will fail. Of established players they are the strongest and making the boldest moves so they have a chance at being a no 2.
But they launch when Netflix has 150 million subscribers. They almost saturated the US market and are quickly devouring international.
Taking market share from a dominant competitor is almost impossible.
If Bob Iger wasn't asleep at the wheel, just like the rest of the industry, Disney would have launched a competitor when Netflix had 10 million US-only customers.
They had a chance then but not now, competing against Netflix's 150 million subscribers and asymmetrical warfare from Amazon.
Netflix lives or dies by being able to create or license content at one price and sell it via subscription revenue at a higher price - it has never been able to do that. It gets it more debt every year trying to keep up.
In the words of Steve Jobs related to Dropbox. Streaming services are now a feature not a product.
All the others are sold as stand alone products you have to individually pay for.
But it’s almost impossible to have a sustainable business when your larger competitors can price your “product” at just above break even as a bundled offering and a platform play.
If they keep this up people might suspect that they want people to watch that content and pay for it. Maybe next the Hollywood Reporter will break the story on how they “bet it all” on theatrical releases, network television, VHS, DVD, Blu-Ray and other things that people pay to watch.
Bob Iger definitely knows how to buy good press. Hollywood Reporter is owned by Guggenheim partners and has deep ties with Disney, including acting as an advisor to the Disney-Fox acquisition.