This is still an ACL issue - that Facebook allowed CA to pull data they weren’t authorized for doesn’t mean making API access is a bad idea.
It increases the attack surface but publicly to everyone.
If I share some information with a friend of a friend, should that information be viewable by an app that the friend of a friend activated? For Cambridge Analytica, the answer was "yes", so Cambridge Analytica was able to scrape a bunch of stuff.
If we make the answer "no", then it won't be possible to build alternate UIs, because the Facebook UI will be able to show my friend of a friend my information, but an alternate UI won't be able to do so.
Cambridge Analytica used posts to get API access to all users (and friends-of-friends) who interacted with those posts, in order to incrementally build a copy of the complete social graph. The process is similar to scraping.