But I'm still going to stand firm on my stance that a doctor, even if they only save a few lives in their career, is providing a more valuable service than I am. There's just no way the time I've saved people has added up to even a few lifetimes.
If we look at the software industry as a whole, it's just very obvious. We're an industry that likes to think we're saving the world, but the reality is that the results of software have been a very mixed bag. Facebook, for example, is pretty much just bad, and there isn't a major company out there that I wouldn't look at as being in some grey area, where it's hard to tell if they are a net positive or negative.
I think you'd pretty easily get trounced making that argument. People would much rather be alive to do something less efficiently than to... not be alive at all. This argument is a bit insane to me.
The only way increased productivity lets people spend more time for themselves is if it is on menial tasks outside of work, and most individual consumers won't pay for software, so then you're often into violating people's privacy to sell ads, which again is pretty hard to justify.
because "helping many people allocate their time towards activities they actually value" was an important premise I stated in the post you originally replied to? I deliberately excluded stuff that merely improves productivity at work (although not everyone is fortunate enough to have a job where they can just leave at five if the work isn't done).
Meanwhile, median life expectancy has skyrocketed, in large part due to new medical treatments and early detection methods. Unless your father was spending 20-30% of each day paying bills, I don't think that's going to do it. I remain unconvinced.
Let's also not forget the drain on interpersonal relations that software has brought about. If your father would have spent that time ok on FB instead I'm not sure we gained anything.