News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Facebook and Speech by jfengel on Friday October 18, 2019 @12:16PM (#21292625)
I don't see what opening Facebook's API would buy us. You'd get different interpretations of the feed, but you'd still be siloed into whatever feed it was you accessed. Cambridge Analytica used FB's data to manipulate the feed and thus the users, but no feed algorithm is going to prevent that. Just the opposite: people would find it even easier to choose a feed algorithm that siloed them further. You could jump to a different one -- but would you?

I don't think it would return nearly as much power to users as he imagines. FB won't make quite the same mistakes as they have in the past, but an enormous amount of information is still public knowledge -- putting your social life in public is the whole point of a social network. People enjoy putting themselves out there and voluntarily, voraciously consume what others put there too. No tech tweak is going to change that, or limit the consequences.

Re:Facebook and Speech by moosey on Friday October 18, 2019 @12:46PM (#21292868)
Based on the history of facebook and its news feed, I believe that the news feed or activity feed in general, unless it is a dumb pipe, should be considered human psychological experimentation. Under this premise, I would submit that not facebook, but instead its curated feeds, should be made illegal.

But then again, the same logic could be applied to advertising/marketing... well, at least some of it, perhaps most.