Eliminating Prop 13 would at least fix some of the misincentives in the housing market so that senior citizens living alone could afford to downsize to a 1BR condo and free up the empty 4BR house for a family with 3 kids.
I think my Mom is typical: because of Prop 13, she can't move. Her property taxes on a new home would be 20X as much.
Due to this, she's kinda 'stuck.' She lives in a house that's larger than what she needs, but she can't justify moving. I think she'd love to "cash out" some of that equity, but she can't.
This is how we got reverse mortgages (which are horrible.)
More importantly, most of California's spending is not to drive growth, but to keep its head above water. Investment is one thing, but never borrow to pay operating expenses if you can help it.
The comparison with Venezuela isn't all that off the mark, structurally. Venezuela also spent dramatically on social programs and redistribution because it could, with an extremely lucrative source of foreign cash. When the gravy train dried up, the whole system collapsed, which is probably what'll happen to California when the tech & entertainment industries dry up (and did happen in 2001 in the wake of the dot-com bust). California probably has several decades before there's a reckoning though: networks of human capital like you have in Silicon Valley and Hollywood are difficult to move or replicate elsewhere.
I often feel like the whole state and local governmental edifice in this state needs to be liquidated. All of it. Both parties. The incompetence especially in urban planning and infrastructure is just unbelievable.
it can be replaced with some very slow tax increase, so market will return into normal pace in 5-10-20 years.
Additionally, Prop 13 is kind of a disincentive to build higher-density buildings because if you tear down a building and build a new one, your tax base will go up to match the newly assessed property value rather than remain at the artificially low level it was at before.
Developers understand this, they want to build, but they are having trouble getting the permits to replace low density SFH with medium- to high-density housing.
Any real solution needs to be a combination of changing zoning/permitting and fixing Prop 13.
measures that include an alternative funding source (e.g., new revenue, new taxes, grants, etc) can be considered on their own merits (measure M in SoCal, for example).
On top of that, in many cases, as the property tax is so low, people who otherwise would not be able to afford such high value properties continue to hold them, leading to an artificial increase in the overall property values.
If Prop-13 is abolished, a lot of properties will enter the market, and overall revenue would increase resolving many of CA's and local government's woes, including that of the public education system.
OTOH, I know that abolishing Prop-13 is an impossibility. Our best hope is that the split tax roll is successful that that would require at least the commercial and industrial property to be regularly reassessed and taxed at their full value.