Oracle bought Sun on a business model that saw them recouping the price of the acquisition not in proceeds from lawsuits but in shoe-leather sales to Oracle and Sun customers (which overlap intensely). Oracle already had the infrastructure to capitalize on that channel with Sun products.
Google had none of that. Had Google bought Sun, the first thing they could have expected would have been a shareholder revolt. The money isn't theirs to spend; it belongs, in large part, to Google's shareholders.
This is bad, but I still don't yet believe buying Sun would have been the better option.
Security from people suing you is probably the most compelling reason you gave here - I see no reason why Google would want to control Java IP and future direction when they can write all the software they need to in house to built on the Java platform to meet their needs.
So is 5-7 billion worth security for people suing you? I guess we'll see, but this is likely the biggest lawsuit related to Java they will ever face, and you can bet they won't make this same mistake again. Unless then pay out several billion dollars, which is unlikely given the tendency of these large technology firms to cross sue and settle with cross licensing agreements, I'd say Google's decision not be buy Sun is still sound at this time.
Just my two cents, I am watching just like the next person from the sidelines, this should be interesting.
But even if you just consider the suing part - this is potentially not just limited to Google but also their OHA members. So if Larry sues everyone in OHA and handset makers couldn't afford to pay what Larry asks - that could end up hurting Android.
i was far from all this politics, but made a few google searches - is this about ASF leaving JCP? then, as far as i understood, these issues are all related, to Harmony, suing etc.
so maybe Java wouldn't be hurt? just specs would be changed more tyrannically...
(java my favorite language, don't make me sad :)
That would have been better for two reasons - Oracle is screwing up bad with the JCP and it's going to hurt Java - May be Google could have been a better steward. Secondly Google relies so much on Java not only for Android but also for many other things - it is almost idiotic not to buy the IP.
I guess they had their reasons to not pursue - I can't imagine what those were.