Re:After 184 years, Cherokees seek House delegate seat promi...
by snagglegaggle on Wednesday October 16, 2019 @07:02PM
(#21276992)
But they are outside the scope in very important ways this glosses over and which does make them much more sovereign than a state, such as sin taxes (cigarettes) and gun law enforcement (a PMC was incorporated in and trading fully automatic weapons through Indian territory). The basis for those is what is important.
Re:After 184 years, Cherokees seek House delegate seat promi...
by celticmusic on Thursday October 17, 2019 @10:05AM
(#21282154)
It's very simple. It's federal land and therefore cannot be taxed by the local governments.
Re:After 184 years, Cherokees seek House delegate seat promi...
by snagglegaggle on Thursday October 17, 2019 @09:47PM
(#21287958)
I'm not totally sold on this interpretation, I've interacted with enough territorial land that I got the impression it is completely left to the tribes. It may technically be "under federal jurisdiction" but if a treaty ceded any or most right to law enforcement then it's independent.
Re:After 184 years, Cherokees seek House delegate seat promi...
by celticmusic on Friday October 18, 2019 @09:58AM
(#21291371)
Then you disagree with the interpretation of the US Supreme Court, take it up with them.
Governments set laws based upon land areas. This is why we have things like county lines, state lines, city lines, etc.
But these local governments have no jurisdiction over federal land. This is why you can have a federal building in the middle of a city, and that city's laws do not apply to the building, or the land around the building (that's held by the US government).
Native land is technically federal land that's held on behalf of the tribes. And THIS is why local laws don't apply to native land.
It's a common misconception that native american tribes are sovereign. They're considered 'domestic dependent nations', but not sovereign. This is why, for example, the US can limit their ability to issue drivers licenses and travel VISA's.