Re:What’s New in Python 3.8
by Sean1708 on Tuesday October 15, 2019 @03:17AM
(#21256251)
How would this hypothetical syntax differ from the walrus operator? I.e. what is hard to understand with the walrus operator that wouldn't be with this new hypothetical syntax and why?
[ Parent
| on HN ]
I think it could avoid cases where you "abuse" the walrus operator and make code harder to understand than necessary. E.g. things like:
if (value := func()) and another_condition:
...
Or: if another_condition or (value := func()):
...
Or: x=1
my_list = [x := x+1, x := x-1]
etc.Ah ok, so you'd essentially allow it in fewer contexts? I would definitely have supported that, although I do think combining walrus with other boolean expressions in if and while is super useful and not particularly hard to understand.