Re:Apple’s diabolical plan to screw your iPhone
by elai on Friday January 21, 2011 @02:07AM
(#2126703)
What advantage is there for torx vs. this pentalobe screw?
Re:Apple’s diabolical plan to screw your iPhone
by bradleyland on Saturday January 22, 2011 @12:50AM
(#2130046)
I'm no engineer, but here's my guess:
At these tiny sizes torx bits end up with some very thin material at the tips of the star pattern. The pentalobe has one fewer tips and the curves are inverse, resulting in more meterial in the bit and less in the fastener head. That makes for a more durable tool at the expense of the fastener durability. These screws weren't intended for frequent removal though, so it's a good trade-off from a tooling perspective.
Re:Apple’s diabolical plan to screw your iPhone
by regularfry on Friday January 21, 2011 @06:11AM
(#2127073)
My guess is that you'll get less tool head wear with pentalobe, but torx are in more peoples' toolboxes.
I don't mean that like it's a bad thing. If you've ever had to reach up behind an instrument panel and attempt to guide a #00 philips screw in to its destination, you'll quickly come to appreciate the ingenuity of these odd-ball fastener types.
Another common cause is automated assembly. Fasteners like torx screws work better with automated machinery because they don't suffer from cam-out.
What I'm getting at is that it was probably an engineering decision, not a device security decision.