News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:AT&T mauled in oral arguments in arguing for "personal pr... by Natsu on Thursday January 20, 2011 @04:14PM (#2125285)
I read about this on the SCOTUS blog and it really stood out for the reasons you mention. But there was also the part where one of the justices mentioned that they'd always construed the parts of this statute narrowly and the FCC counsel actually said that they're prefer not to interpret personal privacy too narrowly due to their broader interests (i.e. not wanting to gut it for everyone), only to find out later that the justice was essentially trying to help him argue against AT&T's arguments.

Like you said, highly unusual.

Re:AT&T mauled in oral arguments in arguing for "personal pr... by boredguy8 on Thursday January 20, 2011 @04:24PM (#2125340)
The government doesn't want it construed too narrowly for reasons other than relate to this case--and isn't to defend the people, but rather to defend the Government's ability to withhold things via FOIA exemptions. The Justice's "help" in arguing for a narrow interpretation here would hurt the Government in later cases where they also want to redact information.