News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:AT&T mauled in oral arguments in arguing for "personal pr... by boredguy8 on Thursday January 20, 2011 @04:09PM (#2125264)
My favorite line of questioning was the Breyer/Scalia comment:

       JUSTICE BREYER: Well, one reason might be 
  that this has really never been a problem because all 
  the legitimate -- or most of them, anyway -- that these 
  organizations that have interests in privacy are 
  actually taken care of by the other 17 exemptions here. 
       JUSTICE SCALIA: Another reason might be 
  that personal -- nobody ever thought that 
  personal privacy would cover this.
I think that combined with the burdens analysis from Scalia is much more damning:

       JUSTICE SCALIA: Is it the burden of the 
  government to show that they intended to exclude 
  corporations, or is it your burden to show that this 
  exception was meant to include corporations? I would 
  think the latter is where the burden lies in this case. 
       MR. KLINEBERG: Well, Justice Scalia, our -­ 
  our burden is to -- is to defend our view of the 
  statute. 
       JUSTICE SCALIA: Well, but if you're asking 
  the government to show that the -- there was an intent 
  to exclude corporations, I don't think that's their 
  burden. I think it's your burden to show that this 
  exemption was intended to include corporations.
       MR. KLINEBERG: I agree, Your Honor, that we 
  are -- our burden is to demonstrate to you why the words 
  "personal privacy" in the statute apply to corporations. 
If the Government had to demonstrate that Congress intended to exempt corporations, none of Robert's questions matter. It might weaken AT&T's case, but it wouldn't destroy it. That the Court & AT&T agree that AT&T needs to demonstrate that Congress intended to exempt the privacy of corporations and that 35 years of FOIA requests don't have a single example of such a decision is what really damages AT&T's position.

And Mr. Yang closed well:

  Now, AT&T has given up on the grammatical 
  imperative that guided exclusively the court of appeals 
  decision in this case, there's nothing left. AT&T can 
  provide no example where the term personal privacy has 
  ever been used to refer to a corporation, much less a 
  foreign government or state or local government in any 
  context, whether it be FOIA, the law generally, or even 
  in common usage. 
Also, for what it's worth, one other 'fun line' came at the expense of Mr. Yang. Justice Scalia:

  Well, I'm not going to help 
  the government's position if the government doesn't want 
  to be helped. I'm happy to leave you where you put 
  yourself.

There are no comments on this comment yet.