Re:JavaScript Interview Question
by bcrescimanno on Thursday January 20, 2011 @12:49PM
(#2124486)
"The value of i is figured out only when the link is clicked."
This makes it sound a bit like magic. A more accurate description is that the usage of the variable "i" within the closure is simply a reference to i in the outer function--not a copy of the value.
A great follow-up is to describe the memory implications of what they've done here and how memory use can be improved.
ahh thank you this makes more sense. If I understand you correctly...
- each list item has a pointer to a function: alert(i) (functions are first class objects)
- the value of i is determined from the outer function (which is in some unraveled way the for(i=0; i<els.length; i++)) because it is within the scope of the above function
-link item executes alert(i) with i = 4, when clicked.
The behaviour is due to the fact that variables in JavaScript are scoped to the function, although as that code is in the global scope and lacks a var declaration it will live under the global object (window in this case). So in that example each closure captures the same variable hence 4 being produced within each alert(). For more info see: https://developer.mozilla.org/en/Core_JavaScript_1.5_Guide/C...
each list item alerts 4 when clicked. This has to do with closures in js. The way I understood it (and please correct if inaccurate) is that each list item has an event listener that calls function: alert(i). However, it's not true that each list item has its own value for i. The value of i is figured out only when the link is clicked.
Once script finishes, i has the value 4, and when clicked on, each list item draws from this value of i instead of the one in which it is originally assigned.