Re:Attack of the trolls - managing your online reputation
by lazy_nerd on Thursday January 20, 2011 @11:03AM
(#2124041)
We do have some clues on who he represents but realized that finger-pointing is not going to help. I hope whoever was behind this got the message and stops messing from now onwards.
Re:Attack of the trolls - managing your online reputation
by DanielBMarkham on Thursday January 20, 2011 @11:07AM
(#2124054)
Yes but you're wasting my time as the reader.
I'm not saying you have to call out folks or be mean to them. I'm saying that if you write a story it should have a plot. A point. Some dramatic tension. A Thesis. Something. This story did not seem to have that.
I'm sure it will work wonders for your purpose -- which I take it to be making sure he got the message -- but as a reader I'm really not very interested in your purpose. Sorry. If it makes you feel any better, people don't give a hoot about the purpose of my stories either -- except as a way to entertain them.
Like I said, the critique was meant in the spirit of friendship. From the large number of votes, it appears some people found real value in your story, but I'm just at a loss to see what it was. That's all.
There's a story to illustrate this, but then -- and this is the kicker -- we never find out who the guy is or what his beef was. If we had, it would have been an acceptable story. But as it is, I can't see what people will get of value from spending their time reading it (Aside from the commercial value the writers got, of course, and I don't begrudge them that. Just trying to help them with providing a better trade for the reader next time)
This article promised to be a great detective story, with lots of twists and perhaps with a surprise ending. But it wasn't that. That makes it frustrating.