News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Seizing the Means of Knowledge Production by ralusek on Saturday October 12, 2019 @02:36PM (#21235218)
It's always interesting to see Hayek's words, followed by a timestamp. Similar, although less recent at nearly 25 years ago, is this Peter Thiel video discussing the illusion of multiculturalism in 1996 https://youtu.be/qTPOBEdc7OI?t=722.

The degree to which radically far left ideology is taught in university is one of the most prevalent contributors to the current political schism. America has been primarily liberal since its inception, but there has been this slow creep of an entirely new, wholly incompatible, and entirely illiberal moral/economic framework.

The modern product of the American university is generally skeptical of anything resembling a meritocracy, instead believing that the major forces that will dictate the outcomes one will receive are mostly divorced from their actions, and instead to be determined by the factions they belong to. Most notably, one's racial and gender identity are brought to the foreground as bar none the primary contributors to the outcomes an individual will encounter. Not too far behind is the usual suspect of economic class, where "boomers" and "landlords" are the new bourgeois, and debt-laden millennial college graduate is the proletariat class. The degree to which people are skeptical of markets and a market value associated with their actions is so immense, that the idea that someone with a CS degree having a vastly greater market value than an individual with a degree in Critical Race theory is simply met with derision akin to "but muh STEM."

Re:Seizing the Means of Knowledge Production by llamataboot on Sunday October 13, 2019 @12:54AM (#21238460)
Meanwhile, in the United States, the black and white wealth gap continues completely unchanged for over 50 years, despite having addressed "racism". Wealth disparities have increased to levels not seen in generations. Your income remains tightly coupled and correlated to your parents income. Etc Etc Etc.

So basically, from any actual social scientific perspective, meritocracy always has been the bullshit fantasy of charlatan "economists" dolling their philosophy of human nature in the disguise of econometric models and regression equations.

Get back to me when you have evidence to support your claims and not just whining about "but muh SJWs", until then you can decide who felt this way about landlords

"The landlords, like all other men, love to reap where they never sowed, and demand a rent even for the natural produce of the earth."

Re:Seizing the Means of Knowledge Production by mikemotherwell on Sunday October 13, 2019 @03:24AM (#21238964)
Anger at these things obscures the ability to find a solution. When you say "the black and white wealth gap continues completely unchanged for over 50 years', I get that is hyperbole, but surely it has changed in some ways, if not on aggregate then in specific locales, in the curve of the distribution... in SOME way.

Given that lots of other things have changed in society, if this gap has stayed the same as an average or median on the whole, that is speaking to something deeper. So what, exactly?

Thomas Sowell makes the point that average ages vary by race: https://www.tsowell.com/spracecu.html and there must be other factors, like where races live. Asians being based in San Francisco pre Silicon Valley's boom has surely had a positive affect on their collective income and wealth.

I really wish there was a clear cut answer, but there self evidently isn't one, unless we believe that every change in society in the last 50 years was made for cynical reasons. So there must be all sorts of answers in the data, sliced properly, that could lead us to a more equitable future.

Re:Seizing the Means of Knowledge Production by kaens on Sunday October 13, 2019 @05:27AM (#21239411)
> that is speaking to something deeper. So what, exactly?

the lingering effects of hundreds of years of overt oppression of both the individual and systemic sort.

this whole thing is like telling a bunch of contestants in a race that they have to start a minute late and aren't allowed to practice and then pretending like that's not going to be a factor in their finish times.

Re:Seizing the Means of Knowledge Production by burntoutfire on Sunday October 13, 2019 @03:07PM (#21242216)
That does not undermine the thesis that the society is basically a meritocracy - it rewards everyone proportional to their contributions, it's just that some people are poised by birth to be able to contribute more than others.

If US weren't a meritocracy, they would promote incompetent people to positions of power. This for to a large degree does not happen - for example, you can't get a $500k FAANG job just because you have an uncle there. On the other hand, if you were born in a family with right values, have the right genes and worked your ass off in school, you are a powerhouse in terms of your ability to contribute and will get that job (simplification, of course).

Re:Seizing the Means of Knowledge Production by RugnirViking on Sunday October 13, 2019 @08:49PM (#21244390)
"If US weren't a meritocracy, they would promote incompetent people to positions of power. This for to a large degree does not happen - for example, you can't get a $500k FAANG job just because you have an uncle there."

I think you'll find that a large and potentially growing number of americans disagree profoundly with this statement. Higher-paid = works harder/produces more is pretty much at the core of this disagreement

Specifically your claim that the US (or the west more generally) doesn't promote incompetent people to positions of power would be completely laughable to pretty much everyone I know (and I don't even mean anything regarding the government). Of course my peers are generally young, and university educated like myself, and I am from europe, not NA, but even my right-wing friends don't hold it self evident that a person in a position of power is automatically competent. We've all worked with and under far too many frustratingly underqualified or straight-up clueless people to give such a notion any credit at all.

Re:Seizing the Means of Knowledge Production by llamataboot on Monday October 14, 2019 @03:30PM (#21251851)
Well-connected parents get you into well-connected schools, which get you into well-compensated jobs. I'll take your FAANG example and raise you all of Wall St.
Re:Seizing the Means of Knowledge Production by llamataboot on Monday October 14, 2019 @03:28PM (#21251838)
This is nitpicking the basic fact that the wealth gap between white Americans and African-Americans is basically unchanged. Go take a look at the graphs yourself!
Re:Seizing the Means of Knowledge Production by agsilvio on Sunday October 13, 2019 @08:13AM (#21239981)
This reads poorly.
Re:Seizing the Means of Knowledge Production by morningseagulls on Sunday October 13, 2019 @10:06AM (#21240408)
>The modern product of the American university is generally skeptical of anything resembling a meritocracy

A little-known fact about the word "meritocracy"[0] is that it's a recent invention, coined by Baron Young of Dartington[1] in his satirical work[2] outlining how dystopian a society organised as a meritocracy would be.

[0] https://en.wiktionary.org/wiki/meritocracy

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Michael_Young,_Baron_Young_of_...

[2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Rise_of_the_Meritocracy

Re:Seizing the Means of Knowledge Production by mrep on Sunday October 13, 2019 @07:41AM (#21239868)
> The degree to which radically far left ideology is taught in university is one of the most prevalent contributors to the current political schism.

I'm super curious to know where you are getting this from because I went to a public state school surrounded by cornfields in the midwest and this wasn't my experience in any way shape or form. I cannot recall any my friends changing their political stances, but then again, we didn't talk politics really. I do know quite a few though that came in republican, left republican, and voted for trump.

> Most notably, one's racial and gender identity are brought to the foreground as bar none the primary contributors to the outcomes an individual will encounter. Not too far behind is the usual suspect of economic class, where "boomers" and "landlords" are the new bourgeois, and debt-laden millennial college graduate is the proletariat class.

I cannot ever recall having had a single conversation in college about any of this.

> The degree to which people are skeptical of markets and a market value associated with their actions is so immense, that the idea that someone with a CS degree having a vastly greater market value than an individual with a degree in Critical Race theory is simply met with derision akin to "but muh STEM."

I'm probably unique in this case as I took multiple economics classes and read probably a dozen more textbooks in my spare time and the answer to this became quite obvious with just basic econ. It's a shame some/more (my highschool incidentally did require one consumer economics class) economics isn't a required course.

Re:Seizing the Means of Knowledge Production by andrekandre on Saturday October 12, 2019 @05:37PM (#21236552)
> Most notably, one's racial and gender identity are brought to the foreground as bar none the primary contributors to the outcomes an individual will encounter.

do you have any hard evidence if this?

> people are skeptical of markets and a market value associated with their actions

assuming that is true, why is that?

Re:Seizing the Means of Knowledge Production by EGreg on Sunday October 13, 2019 @01:19AM (#21238519)
People are skeptical of markets because of various factors:

1. That the rich get richer, so to speak, and inequality grows, leading to increasing numbers of people not being able to afford basic rent.

2. That government is captured by markets and corporate welfare is rampant, while welfare programs for the poor are cut

3. People are not LLCs and we don’t want them to just go bankrupt and run out of resources because they can’t earn enough to cover basic needs. This is becoming especially pertinent with automation and outsourcing reducing demand for local labor.

4. That traditionally valued activities such as a homemaker raising kids have zero market value now that both sexes work

and so on.

Non-market solutions such as a single payer for universal health insurance, universal education etc. are considered essential in any modern democracy. This is called social democracy.

Re:Seizing the Means of Knowledge Production by specialist on Sunday October 13, 2019 @09:43AM (#21240295)
Here's a different take on markets from a commie pinko liberal:

Open markets are just a tool for determining price between many parties. When well designed and regulated, open markets can be efficient at that task.

Closed markets, like single payer healthcare, are a viable alternative when the players decide that price isn't the most important factor. Meaning they're optimizing for other factors. With single payer, maximizing public health is deemed most important.

Rigged markets give all markets a bad name. aka winner-takes-all, late stage capitalism, oligarchy, laissez faire, Freedom Markets™ (my own pejorative).

Re:Seizing the Means of Knowledge Production by slowswift on Saturday October 12, 2019 @05:39PM (#21236561)
> The degree to which people are skeptical of markets and a market value associated with their actions is so immense

Similarly, the degree to which market advocates, themselves, exhibit skepticism about the market mechanism vis-a-vis their own intellectual products is so immense, in fact, that the idea that ideas achieving widespread adoption within the marketplace of ideas do, indeed, have vastly greater value than those with inferior adoption is simply met with comparably-inarticulate derision.

Re:Seizing the Means of Knowledge Production by roenxi on Saturday October 12, 2019 @08:33PM (#21237371)
Ideas aren't a great place to push free market ideals; especially because so many ideas are basically anti-freedom and anti-market. How often does anyone come up with "let people sort it out themselves, bearing the costs and consequences" as a new idea? When it is suggested it is rare to see someone championing it with enthusiasm and to wide acclaim. Compare that to the "Lets order people to [activity]" style ideas that are common and suggested in many forms.

Using market forces to measure the value of an idea is not clever. Ideas that are to be put into practice should be assessed primarily by whether they are grounded in evidence or not, and secondarily by whether people are willing to cope with the consequences of the idea going wrong.

An idea being popular or gaining popularity does not make it a valuable idea (or indeed a good idea). That stands in stark contrast to economic forces which measure resource creation and destruction with a cruel accuracy.

Re:Seizing the Means of Knowledge Production by anonuser123456 on Saturday October 12, 2019 @10:02PM (#21237800)
You're making a derisive comment about inarticulate derision in a sentence with 7 commas.
Re:Seizing the Means of Knowledge Production by brownbat on Sunday October 13, 2019 @09:23AM (#21240221)
The Aspen Summit a few years ago had a forum where someone pushed for major news outlets to promote more intellectual, nuanced content, and one rep from a major network pushed back. They pointed out that the consumer of that sort of content is going to the ballet, or trying the new restaurant by some named chef, or attending the Aspen Summit, not staying at home watching 24-hour news. That sophisticated audience is out doing interesting things, they might watch occasionally, but aren't a consistent enough news audience to shape content. "We run the market test against PBS every night."

Best thing I can imagine is that policy wonks writing in low subscription specialty journals are a bit like arthouse films. Sure, the indie films lose in the market to blockbusters, and wonky policy journals don't get a tiny fraction of the eyeballs of 24 hour news. But it's more likely for important new ideas to be born in the niche, experimental market than vice versa. They're losing the market test, but contributing a lot of positive externalities by influencing the influencers, they're just not able to capture all those returns.

Re:Seizing the Means of Knowledge Production by wrnr on Saturday October 12, 2019 @07:30PM (#21237085)
Haha, but in all seriousness I'd like for the social sciences to conduct a study on how widespread the adoption their ideas is.
Re:Seizing the Means of Knowledge Production by EGreg on Sunday October 13, 2019 @01:13AM (#21238505)
I think this is called by many “postmodernism” and it is found on the right and on the left - though far more on the left. Foucalt was a big proponent. He rejected the label but others ran with it:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Postmodernism

Re:Seizing the Means of Knowledge Production by friendlybus on Sunday October 13, 2019 @06:08AM (#21239554)
A lot of skepticism falls under postmodernism, but it's not useful to label it that. Are we going to rise only from our skepticism?
Re:Seizing the Means of Knowledge Production by lasagnaphil on Sunday October 13, 2019 @02:59AM (#21238855)
No, postmodernism is not identity politics. This video explains this very well: https://youtu.be/26fIBA7O5Ag

Although postmodernism isn’t as strictly defined as other philosophical movements, one can still clearly say what it doesn’t represent. Postmodern philosophy is typically associated on the internet as feminism/multiculturalism/Cultural Marxism, although it is none of that at all. It may have some loose ties by influencing some feminists and critical theorists through some scholars such as Foucault and Deleuze, but you can’t really mash all of them into a same philosophical movement.

Re:Seizing the Means of Knowledge Production by EGreg on Sunday October 13, 2019 @11:04AM (#21240736)
Some of my FB friends are climate change denialists invoking postmodernism whenever they need to disagree with scientific consensus. People on the right also invoke postmodern ideas when they don’t want to have evolution being taught in their schools and so on.
Re:Seizing the Means of Knowledge Production by friendlybus on Sunday October 13, 2019 @06:03AM (#21239541)
The premise of that video is wrong when applied to Peterson. It misrepresents Peterson in the first minute by taking Peterson's discussion about pomo neomarxism to be his proclaimed understanding of postmodernists. He isn't talking about postmodernists in the video, he is talking about a group of people that apply both neomarxist and postmodern ideas at the same time.

Cuck philosophy forwarding Judith butler in the video description as a credible source is damaging to his reputation. Other of his videos have been debunked before.

Re:Seizing the Means of Knowledge Production by Zarath on Sunday October 13, 2019 @03:47AM (#21239061)
This can't be stressed enough. Though I think this idea gets pushed quite a bit from Jordan Peterson and the rest of the reactionary right YT-sphere
Re:Seizing the Means of Knowledge Production by snagglegaggle on Saturday October 12, 2019 @11:59PM (#21238273)
>Most notably, one's racial and gender identity are brought to the foreground as bar none the primary contributors to the outcomes an individual will encounter.

To be fair parental income is the best indicator of child income and those things you list are proxies for parental income. That said I do agree with your point, though I think market skepticism is largely a separate issue from forced multiculturalism and identity politics. The market is generally dysfunctional for the working class and people want to blame something for it. On the other side the dysfunction is blamed for different things.

This hurts me particularly as over-correction w.r.t race/social class has made it very hard to attend school despite good grades and extracurricular performance.

Re:Seizing the Means of Knowledge Production by barry-cotter on Sunday October 13, 2019 @06:27AM (#21239618)
> To be fair parental income is the best indicator of child income and those things you list are proxies for parental income.

Intelligence predicts scholastic achievement irrespective of SES factors: Evidence from Brazil

https://s3.amazonaws.com/academia.edu.documents/45855748/j.i...

This study explores whether or not intelligence tests' scores predict individual differences in scholastic achievement irrespective of SES factors such parents' income and education. The variables of interest are analyzed considering three independent samples of participants comprising a total of 641 children. The participants belonged to a Brazilian School characterized by broad and representative ranges in intelligence, scholastic achievement, and SES factors. The results indicate that SES factors do not predict children differences in scholastic achievement, whereas children's intelligence tests' scores predict their scholastic differences. These results underscore personal intelligence as a genuine predictor of individual differences in scholastic achievement.

Re:Seizing the Means of Knowledge Production by CM30 on Sunday October 13, 2019 @08:45AM (#21240085)
> Most notably, one's racial and gender identity are brought to the foreground as bar none the primary contributors to the outcomes an individual will encounter. Not too far behind is the usual suspect of economic class, where "boomers" and "landlords" are the new bourgeois, and debt-laden millennial college graduate is the proletariat class.

Personally, my experience is that a lot of these individuals outright dismiss class inequality altogether, and put an unwarranted level of importance on gender/race as the defining factors of someone's life. For them, it seems like it doesn't matter if some white man is dirt poor working a terrible job in an area with no economic prospects, merely being male or white is somehow being 'privileged'.

The skepticism about markets and market value is definitely a worrying trend though. As is the general disdain towards capitalism and everything associated with a free market, which feels like people misunderstanding both of those things. Corporate corruption and poor regulations are certainly issues, but that doesn't mean the underlying concept is bad too.

Re:Seizing the Means of Knowledge Production by nuncanada on Saturday October 12, 2019 @09:17PM (#21237590)
Do you realize that what you are complaining about has the same problematic root as what you think are good ideas? They are all pseudo-scientific ideology. Hayek and neoliberalism just as much as the radical left ideology...