Re:Larry Wall has approved renaming Perl 6 to Raku
by Ultimatt on Saturday October 12, 2019 @05:59PM
(#21236671)
Raku isnt falling from public favor, it hasn't made it yet. It's an entirely different language to Perl 5. Like the difference between C and C# or Java.
Re:Larry Wall has approved renaming Perl 6 to Raku
by zumu on Saturday October 12, 2019 @07:30PM
(#21237082)
Yea, sorry I'm not super familiar with the project, but that is the general vibe I get about Perl.
Interestingly enough 落(raku) also has the connotation of failure or missing the target, so not very auspicious in the context of a new language either!
Also, while 'raku' is the reading for 楽, which connotes easy, simple and other good things, it is also the reading for a bunch of other characters--namely, 落, which means or carries the connotation of falling, declining or otherwise missing the mark.
When I see the 'raku' transliteration in the context of Perl, I think of 落. Not sure if that says something about my subconscious perception of Perl or not, but I can't help but think 'Raku' is a bad choice for the name of a language mired in indecision and falling from public favor.
On another note, I find the inclination of tech projects towards poorly translated Japanese words amusing. It nicely compliments the phenomena you see in the use of random English words for the naming of Japanese cars, condo buildings, and other 'prestigious' products. So if you find that ridiculous, you should find these 'Japanese' technology names ridiculous as well.