News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Relearning to Type by Waterluvian on Saturday October 12, 2019 @09:18AM (#21232853)
Has anyone become truly proficient with multiple layouts? Can you shed light on what it's like to switch throughout your day or week?
Re:Relearning to Type by yboris on Saturday October 12, 2019 @09:52AM (#21233101)
I'm 'fluent' in QWERTY and DVORAK. Learned QWERTY when I was 13 years old, learned DVORAK around college years. For DVORAK I used Stamina Typing Tutor - https://typingsoft.com/screenshots.htm It was frustrating at first, but within a few months I only made mistakes with very rarely accessed characters.

Since then I've been able to switch between the layouts swiftly. At work I use Dvorak on my external keyboard, but when I take the laptop with me I switch to QWERTY. The switch is a mental flip akin to talking in another language (I'm fluent in Russian and English).

I think the switch is very worth it. If I was re-doing it, I'd probably learn Colemak instead of Dvorak (apparently it's a slightly better choice for some reasons).

Re:Relearning to Type by yboris on Saturday October 12, 2019 @12:53PM (#21234520)
Just found my tweet from last year urging people to migrate away from QWERTY: https://twitter.com/whyboris/status/1036300736953544704
Re:Relearning to Type by weberc2 on Saturday October 12, 2019 @10:13AM (#21233250)
When I moved to France I would use the Canadian French keyboard layout which was QWERTY-based with subtle changes and a whole bunch of modifiers for different accents above/below standard Roman letters. I was surprised at how quickly I adapted, even to the character variations. It took only a week or so to become proficient. While dvorak et al are certainly more different, I think it isn’t unrealistic to master those layouts in a week or two. Muscle memory is a remarkable thing.
Re:Relearning to Type by zamadatix on Saturday October 12, 2019 @12:10PM (#21234197)
I used to be fluent in QWERTY, Dvorak, Colemak, and Carpalx (i.e. >60 WPM on any of the listed). To learn each I did the cold turkey method the author seems to have settled on as well. The first alternative (Dvorak) took about 2 weeks to get to the same proficiency but I was using a desktop computer for ~16 hours a day during this time period. I followed up with Colemak to see if it really was any better and then heard of Carpalx shortly after that. I ended up liking Carpalx the most though it comes at the cost of not being preinstalled. The Carpalx website has the X11 keyboard definitions, I had to make a custom Windows keyboard layout install package for my work desktop.

Nowadays I'm only fluent in QWERTY and Carpalx since I stopped using the other two once I made my decision but switching is no different for me than when it was 4.

Anyways to answer your question now that the background is out of the way: Switching for me seems to be more a function of how comfortable I am with the layout than anything else by far and I've become extremely comfortable with the layouts I use. I can switch between QWERTY and Carpalx instantly and I very often do e.g. when a game was coded based on the letter sent instead of the scancode or when I'm in an RDP session to a prod box.

The only time things can get jumbled for me is if I'm working in RDP with QWERTY on one monitor and another layout locally. Jumping between I often forget it's a different layout because I haven't consciously switched by triggering the input method toggle keyboard shortcut like I normally would. The solution is simple though: If I'm going to spend a lot of time hopping between the RDP session I'll just toggle to QWERTY globally until I'm done.

I'm a swiper on phones so it makes sense to leave it qwerty since that's what the swiping algorithms target.

Re:Relearning to Type by mkl on Saturday October 12, 2019 @10:06AM (#21233201)
My experience was quite different to that described in this article. Around 20 years ago I switched to Dvorak on my personal computer. It took me about two weeks to get used to it, and maybe four more to gather up to the speed I typed in QWERTY. Throughout this I still used QWERTY on other computers, like the family computer and computers at university.

I had no trouble switching between layouts, and could type 60wpm in each, in consecutive minutes. I tested this when I had my computer in the family room connected to the family computer to transfer files (parallel cable!). I had one keyboard on the desk and the other on my lap and had no difficulty with the different layouts while working on both computers simultaneously.

I never got much faster in Dvorak than QWERTY, but it was much better for my hands on the keyboards of the time.

Re:Relearning to Type by RealWittenstein on Saturday October 12, 2019 @09:31AM (#21232960)
I personally pretty much ditched QWERTY for now (I use it only on my phone).

But I think it's possible to maintain 2 layouts in your muscle memory

Re:Relearning to Type by laylomo2 on Saturday October 12, 2019 @09:52AM (#21233098)
Here’s Jashe Poon getting 158 wpm on a test where his keyboard layout suddenly switches twice so that he ends up typing 20 seconds each of Qwerty, Colemak, and Dvorak: https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=GK8UQGO-qFA