News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:What You Can't Say (2004) by rjblackman on Friday October 11, 2019 @09:52PM (#21230043)
the decision will be made through rational argument. if you are not willing to debate or argue then your position is forfeit (I.E. you are the one with the intolerant philosophy).
Re:What You Can't Say (2004) by cortesoft on Saturday October 12, 2019 @01:32AM (#21230902)
I get frustrated at this line of reasoning; how long do you have to debate it? If the person you are debating keeps bringing up illogical arguments, or says non-sequiturs, or keeps making the same arguments over and over, do you have to keep arguing or 'your position is forfeit'?

Do you have to debate EVERYONE who disagrees with you? Do you have to have the exact same argument with different people, because the second person didn't hear your argument with the first?

I have a friend who trolls me by taking advantage of my need to be rational. He will argue with me, but continue to make more and more non-sensical arguments as we go along. By the end, he will say something like "hah! So you admit hamsters are nocturnal, therefore the sun can't rise in the east!"

At that point I realize he has just been trying to get me angry with irrational argument, so I know I just have to stop arguing.

Just because I refuse to debate him doesn't mean I give up my ability to have a position.

Re:What You Can't Say (2004) by rjblackman on Saturday October 12, 2019 @12:30PM (#21234346)
popper believed that we can convince people through reason. not sure how he would deal with trolls.
Re:What You Can't Say (2004) by gruez on Friday October 11, 2019 @11:52PM (#21230535)
>the decision will be made through rational argument

and what do you do when both sides are at an impasse because they have different axioms?

Re:What You Can't Say (2004) by rjblackman on Saturday October 12, 2019 @01:12AM (#21230825)
then the axioms themselves can be argued until a conclusion is reached, otherwise debate can be suspended. the underlying axiom here is that debate can be had, and that people can be convinced through reason.
Re:What You Can't Say (2004) by Reelin on Saturday October 12, 2019 @01:58AM (#21230968)
> the underlying axiom here is that debate can be had, and that people can be convinced through reason

I take it you haven't seen Twitter (or Facebook, or Reddit, or even SE lately)? Or perhaps you're referring only to in person interactions here, but I've still never witnessed this outside of a STEM setting (and even then, not always).

Re:What You Can't Say (2004) by lmm on Saturday October 12, 2019 @06:42AM (#21232040)
A platform that deliberately limits the length of what can be posted to only the most trivial thoughts turns out to be a poor place for debate? Shocking, that.
Re:What You Can't Say (2004) by rjblackman on Saturday October 12, 2019 @12:22PM (#21234292)
we are talking about karl popper's open society. not sure he knew about social media :)