News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:DuckDuckGo Challenges Google on Privacy (With a Billboard... by dools on Wednesday January 19, 2011 @11:22PM (#2122633)
Turning off HTTP_REFERER doesn't sound like a very good idea. How would you be able to tell how people found you? Knowing what link someone came in from is a great way to see where your site fits into this world wide web of ours.

It sounds to me as if the only issue is 3rd party ad networks. The antidote to this seems to me to be more reasonably the web browser's jurisdiction, ie. making the cookie policy more restrictive by default.

Re:DuckDuckGo Challenges Google on Privacy (With a Billboard... by gnaritas on Wednesday January 19, 2011 @11:30PM (#2122654)
Sorry, accidental downvote while highlighting your question.

> Turning off HTTP_REFERER doesn't sound like a very good idea. How would you be able to tell how people found you?

And what if people in general, by default, don't want you to know that and we just got it wrong by default in the browser?

Re:DuckDuckGo Challenges Google on Privacy (With a Billboard... by dools on Thursday January 20, 2011 @12:11AM (#2122739)
I don't remember anyone ever discussing the referrer as being an issue before 3rd party ad networks became so prevalent.

This type of tracking exists for loads of other types of marketing, too. Promo codes, questionnaires that say "where did you find us?" and things like that.

Above all, there's nothing a website can do maliciously with that information alone. An IP address and the page you came in from, that's all there is. The only thing of concern is a feature being provided by the browser which allows spammer.com to write to a cookie that was created by facebook.com right?

I think that sending around the referrer is a necessary part of the interconnectedness of the web. I've noticed in my referral strings before that other bloggers have linked to articles which I wrote, then I've stopped past that blogger's site to have a read of their stuff.

I've noticed a sharp rise recently in services making use of 3rd party cookies, though: FB connect and OAuth generally, and all of Google's stuff (I use a separate browser to stay logged into gmail and calendar so that I'm not logged in as far as Google is concerned for my normal browsing).

What about having sandboxed browser instances which segment off your various web apps in their own little silos?

Re:DuckDuckGo Challenges Google on Privacy (With a Billboard... by bruceboughton on Thursday January 20, 2011 @03:59AM (#2123120)
OAuth doesn't use cookies, does it?
Re:DuckDuckGo Challenges Google on Privacy (With a Billboard... by dools on Thursday January 20, 2011 @04:50AM (#2123183)
No, you're right it doesn't. But when you sign in with the same identity around the place, that identity is then stored in lots of different places so my perception of being "tracked" has certainly increased with the advent of OAuth.
Re:DuckDuckGo Challenges Google on Privacy (With a Billboard... by dauphin on Wednesday January 19, 2011 @11:26PM (#2122644)
*referrer
Re:DuckDuckGo Challenges Google on Privacy (With a Billboard... by jarek on Thursday January 20, 2011 @12:00AM (#2122710)
Heh, no. The header really is "HTTP_REFERER", and is somewhat notorious for the misspelling.
Re:DuckDuckGo Challenges Google on Privacy (With a Billboard... by dauphin on Thursday January 20, 2011 @12:03AM (#2122716)
Open an English dictionary (the Oxford one if you're serious), and come back. Note my fault if tbl didn't know how to speak English corectly backed then.
Re:DuckDuckGo Challenges Google on Privacy (With a Billboard... by jarek on Thursday January 20, 2011 @12:10AM (#2122735)
Surely whether or not the RFC's authors know how to spell a word has no bearing on how sensible it is to correct the spelling of "HTTP_REFERER"? I mean, if dools had said "HTTP referer" then you might have had a point, but "HTTP_REFERER" unambiguously refers to the name of the header field.
Re:DuckDuckGo Challenges Google on Privacy (With a Billboard... by ezalor on Thursday January 20, 2011 @12:24AM (#2122765)
No need to be pedant dude.
Re:DuckDuckGo Challenges Google on Privacy (With a Billboard... by jarek on Thursday January 20, 2011 @12:56AM (#2122831)
At the risk of taking the joke too far, "pedant" is a noun and requires an article preceding it.
Re:DuckDuckGo Challenges Google on Privacy (With a Billboard... by dools on Thursday January 20, 2011 @12:01AM (#2122713)
It's actually spelled HTTP_REFERER in the PHP $_SERVER superglobal :)

edit: oops, I see someone beat me to it!

Re:DuckDuckGo Challenges Google on Privacy (With a Billboard... by jarek on Thursday January 20, 2011 @12:07AM (#2122729)
It's not just PHP - the HTTP 1.0 specification in RFC 1945 spells it like that.